AITAH for telling my sister that having children wasn’t a job but a responsibility.
I 27M have a sister who’s about 30. This past Monday she had a birthday party for her one child and while we were there my mother, my partner and myself were talking about how exhausted we were from working. For context, my mother works almost all day cleaning houses, my partner just worked a nearly 30hr weekend due to the new Spider-Man movie and I work two jobs both in kitchens.
As we were talking my sister came in and said, “yeah try raising these kids”. She had 3 girls, 11,3,2. My mom looked at her and said “I did, I raised two little assholes”. And the rest of us laughed. My sister looked at us and told her “yeah but you don’t raise these ones”. I told her my sister “you do know that mom raises the one right? Besides how about you work like we do”? My sister stood there and said angrily “my kids are my job”. And before my mom could stop me I said “no one told you to keep popping them out, and the last I checked it took two dumbasses to make a kid. You CHOSE to have them, they’re a responsibility not a job so don’t claim otherwise”. She stormed off and my mom looked at me and said “why would you do that, you know she’s gonna bitch about that later”. I asked her “wasn’t she going to call anyway”?
After that the party went on and we went home. The next day my mom called me and said that my sister was bitching about me and what I said but we both said “she has no room to talk, you (my mom) always worked even when we were little, there’s never an excuse but laziness”. We talked a little more and then my partner and I talked about this more. She said that she agreed with me but like my mom I just say shit and don’t think before hand.
Am I in the wrong about this? Overall I don’t feel like what I told her was just pieces of truth she refuses to hear but I guess I should get other opinions as well.
EDIT: Well, that turned ugly quickly.
Now, in a way I left out pieces of information to see gauge what the average response would be. The result:yeah people think I’m an asshole in more ways than one.
Giving you the base line of information about the situation and the people involved, yeah it was to be expected. Now let me give you some context for why I said what I said.
My sister in short, is a horrible person. She once, as I put in a comment (buried BTW) left the boy she was with (love of her life) to be with her first baby daddy. In doing so, she abandoned him and his young child with our mother in her already cramped apartment.
Then only came back because she found out she was pregnant with my first niece, her first kid.
About a year later, my first niece had to live with my mother, her fiancé, and myself. Again, cramped apartment. I slept in the living room with her, changed her, fed her, and stayed up with her during late nights. I missed school for her, because no one else could. We raised her for probably about 2 years with her mom in and out of the picture.
Then my sister decided no one was helping her and uprooted herself, and her daughter and left to live with her father across the state. Where, in a twist no one saw coming, left her to her own devices.
This is a small glimpse into the person that is my sister. Will this change y’all’s opinion, probably not. But what the hell, give it a try.