AITAH for confronting my sister 29F about her Boyfriend 30sM about his friend request to my partner 24f)?
NOTE: this is an older story but it’s still the topic of a lot of arguments in the family.
At the time my sister 29F was dating someone who I’ll presume was in his 30s, I’ll refer to him as “M”. He encouraged her to become an “open relationship” and this quickly turned into a disaster. Before the story at hand, he had tried to engage a lesbian couple into either a threesome or foursome while staying over for a Halloween party at my Ex’s house (long story). He was repeatedly turned down and it escalated when the lesbian couple told my ex (party host) who then confronted my sister and told her if he didn’t stop they’d have to leave.
Fast forward about a month later and one morning my partner woke up and saw that M sent her a friend request. This was weird on multiple levels because: he didn’t send one to me, my mother, her fiancé or any one else for that matter. I instinctively texted my mother who confirmed that she never got one.
She asked me if I wanted her to handle it but I said that she could but I would also have a few words with her too. I messaged my sister and told her that in basic terms “if your boyfriend thinks he’s slick he isn’t. And he if he tries to do anything else that I’ll happily make it a bigger issue”.
Of course, she denied any ill intent but the truth was there clear as crystal.
Later one while at a party at my mother house he tried to sit behind her and talk to her, I immediately moved her away and told him anything else that comes out of his mouth will be the last thing.
My sister and him broke up a little while later over different issues. Allegedly he broke up with her after another couple refused to have sex with him and he blamed my sister.
My sister tries to blame me for it a year and several other boyfriends later because I got “too defensive over nothing”
To me I was perfectly within my rights towards him but she still resents me for it, was I in the wrong?
EDIT: some people have mentioned that I should have let my partner handle the whole situation. She has massive anxiety issues and has even more difficulty confronting people. I only did what I did because she said I could.