RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/AmItheAsshole • … • u/sleepy_g0lden_st0rm

AITA? My dog pooped on the sidewalk that happened to be in front of a cafe in NYC – Owner was not happy.

I just had an experience that I am not sure how to feel about. I was walking my dog on a commercial street filled with small businesses and shops in Queens, NY. I had just come from the vet and my dog, a beagle mix, had been pretty nervous, so I thought a little walk would be nice.

As we are walking, my dog suddenly stops and poops in the middle of the sidewalk. Now, this is not an ideal place for him to go, and usually he tries to find a grassy spot off to the side, but apparently he needed to go and this was where he was going. This spot he chose to go on the sidewalk happened to be a in front of a cafe (about 4 feet in front of it). I didn't think much of it, or even notice what business I was in front of. I got out a poop bag to pick it up. I picked up the poop in the dog bag and tied a knot. There was a small amount of residue that I couldn't get off of the sidewalk (not sure how to avoid that).

Just as we were about to continue walking, someone pops out of the door (who I assume is the owner of the cafe) and says in a rude tone, "This is a business, don't let your dog poop here (pointing to where the dog had pooped). He should have pooped over there (points to the curb)"

I didn't know how to respond and I think I mustered something like, "This is a sidewalk and this is where he stopped to go."

I didn't feel like I should apologize for anything in this situation so I did not. I was more annoyed than anything. I turned and left without further engaging with the person. I noted the shop and made a mental note to never visit it.

Just for a better visual: This cafe has no outdoor seating. This is just a public sidewalk in front of their cafe that is on a pedestrian street in a big city.

I am not sure what I could have done differently. I picked up the poop. The owner of the cafe didn't need to come out and say anything. They don't own the sidewalk in front of their cafe. This is NYC, we all have to share the sidewalk.

Who's the asshole?

— 0