RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/AmItheAsshole • … • u/Michthan

AITA for not wanting my wife's Brother-In-Law as the godfather for our third child.

The facts:

My wife and I are expecting our third child. We discussed beforehand who we would chose and already told them last weekend: Godfather: My best friend Godmother: My wife's Sister-In-Law Both our other children have only two godparents, which are my sister and my wife's two sisters and brother. No siblings remain to chose as godparent. My wife also has a Brother-In-Law who isn't godparent to any child, but has two brothers. My wife's BIL and SIL are almost as long in the family.

The possibility for assholeness: My wife wants to ask her BIL as third godparent as she feels he will feel excluded. I don't want to chose him as we decided not to before my wife was plagued by guilt. I also think guilt is not a good reason to chose him. I think we should have chose him because we wanted too. AITA for not wanting to chose him?

— 0