RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ArcRaiders • … • u/Senator_Cheeks

PvPvE in Arc Raider

The most fun I had in the game was when it launched, before I realized how the matchmaking worked and I thought that anybody could be a threat. In reality nobody was a threat because I wasn't a threat and therefore I was being put in lobbies with people that didn't want to fight.

Hanging out with people is fun. Going on adventures is fun. But I don't want to play Arc Raiders to meet people. The reason those things were fun to me was because there was an additional social layer on top of the interaction, the suspense of knowing that I could be betrayed at any moment, that the person I was approaching could be unfriendly, that the random raider I crossed paths with suddenly and out of nowhere, in a moment of panicked vulnerability, could be dangerous, and the potential relief when that turned out to not be the case, the elation when it turns out that that raider wants to help me... all of the additional maneuvering i had to do to navigate these potentialities. All of this is only possible in a PvPvE scenario.

THAT WAS THE POINT! Meeting people WAS NEVER THE POINT! (for me) Just like how in Among Us talking with people is not the point, it's navigating personalities, figuring out who's lying, who's relaying accurate information and who's relaying false information by accident. Being betrayed always hurts, but for me, it hurts in the same way that watching a horror movie is scary. There's a difference between being scared in a safe enviornment and being scared in a dangerous enviornment, one facilitates fun and has no real consequences.

That is the magic of a PvPvE game like this. The problem with this genre of game is that you will always have four subsections of players. One who are attracted to the game for the PVE, one who are attracted to the game for the PVP, one who are attracted to both PVE and PVP separately, and one that is attracted to the game for the tension between the two.

The people who are attracted to the game for either the PVE or the PVP will always be at odds with eachother because one's experience comes at the expense of the other. PVP people are actively ruining the fun of PVE people by engaging with PVP, and PVE people are actively ruining the fun of PVP people by being upset about it. Each side will always want the game to go in a different direction that is fundamentally at odds with each other, for the sake of their own fun. PVE people want their own lobbies. PVP people want mixed lobbies because without PVE people there is nobody to prey upon.

The PROBLEM with seperate lobbies is that with them the game can no longer be a PvPvE game. Players will self segregate, PVE people will never play with PVP people, PVP people will be forced into entirely aggressive lobbies, and people that enjoy the tension created by PvPvE scenarios won't be able to find it because to do so would require going into PVP lobbies which are now dominated by people who don't want to PVE.

This is what would happen with seperate lobbies. There is no fix that maintains the spirit of the game as it claims to be or one that makes every subsection of players happy. This problem within the community is inevitable because of the very nature of the game, and has existed to the same extent within every PvPvE game that has existed.

This has all already happened in Arc Raiders. Embark just claims it isn't the case. This is a game with a PvP mode and a PvE mode, with the ability for PvP players to game their way into the PvE mode. That's how the sorting system already works. If you fight no one, not even to defend yourself, you will be placed in lobbies with people who don't fight. If you defend yourself from somebody who's gamed the system, you will be pushed up in the aggression ladder, forcing you to defend yourself again, which further pushes you up the ladder until you're in full PvP. You either fight no one or you fight everyone. People like me who enjoy the PvPvE are already not cattered to. Nobody is fully happy.

— 0