A couple of interesting endings today - Fellow storytellers, what would you have done?
Hosted my third BOTC day as Storyteller today and had two fun games. Both ended in weird ways and I made decisions after careful consideration of the situation. Curious to see how others would have handled it.
Game 1:
Strings Pulling, which is basically Trouble Brewing + Marionette. The evil team told the Marionette about 2/3 of the way through the game - they were convinced they were the drunk because their Washerwoman information didn't add up.
Final three was the Scarlet Woman turned Imp, the Poisoner and the Marionette. I asked if anyone wanted to nominate and there was a lot of discussion. If all three had agreed to not nominate, that was the win for Evil right there. Eventually the Scarlet Imp, who had the most heat going into the final three, nominated the Poisoner, which didn't get enough votes. The town was urging the Marionette to nominate the demon and in a moment of confusion, they did so. Defeat was well and truly snatched out of the jaws of victory as every good ghost vote came out and they killed the demon.
Afterwards the discussion was around the rules around the ending. The Scarlet Woman/Imp thought they would just automatically win as it was all evil players in the final day. I explained that no, Evil only wins if there are two alive players, one of which is the demon. I wanted the day to play out because if they hadn't convinced the Marionette and conveyed the plan enough, something could still go catastrophically wrong - which is what happened.
Game 2:
Bad Moon Rising. A whole bunch of stuff happened but the last night was the critical one. The sailor had already sussed out the Po and drank with them the last night. However the town failed to execute the Po on the last day as the Evil team forced a tie, so in my opinion that was their last chance to do so, so I made the Sailor drunk and the Po killed the Sailor and Grandmother to end the game (they had elected not to kill the previous night)