RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Boruto • … • u/Sweet_Whisper123

How do you (Manga readers, especially) reconcile with the history behind Sarada's 3rd Tomoe?

As a preface, we already know about the obvious history behind her 1st Tomoe and the Anime did a good job in exploring the history behind her 2nd Tomoe (especially since it used unexplored Manga materials such the VII Inner Kara member Deepa) but unfortunately the Anime really had to ruin the canonity of the Manga timeline by withholding Sarada's 3rd Tomoe in Boro's arc, as the consequence even if the Anime return in the future and explore the story behind her 3rd Tomoe it will never fit the Manga's canonity anymore.

Now before anyone raise the issue of Anime-canon vs Manga canon, I must say that the relationship between the Anime and Manga when it comes to canonity is murky at best so at times it's fair to call it 50-50, i.e. Sumire coming from Anime, the Trip to Land of Water being referenced in Manga, Inner Kara realistically start from number I to IX and the Anime introduced the missing VII and VIII members, etc, but there are also contradictions such as Sarada's being made in to Chunin and her 3rd Tomoe being withheld (realistically, her Chunin title can easily be fixed with demotion but the 3rd Tomoe moment has gone past its 'supposed' timeline).

So let me ask you dear Manga readers; will you accept the history behind Sarada's 3rd Tomoe once the Anime return and explore that? (Y'know, we can always fanonize that and pretend it actually happened before Boro's arc). If not, would you really rather let it be a mystery forever?

Personally, I have a good solution, some people don't realize this but Sarada's 3rd Tomoe actually debuted in the novel first before it appeared in the Manga so I think the Anime should solidify the history behind her 3rd Tomoe using the novel storyline, this way even though the Anime has betrayed Manga's representation at least it'll work as a paradox instead of total contradiction, seeing that the novels also hold canonity leverage on their own. What do you think?

— 0