Observation: Good Coaching Occurred Right In Front Of Us
# And we missed it, because we aren't use to it
**An objective observation is that the browns think Watson SHOULD be better than Sanders.** But for some reason, Watson would go out in practice and shit his pants. That what was reported through the first 7 days of minicamp and even the last stretch of OTAs. He at some point lost his confidence. Recall that during the final stretch of OTAs, Shedeur had "closed the gap".
But there was a problem
Watson was/is the browns preference as qb1. This isn't a hottake. They've told us over and over. They've tried to soft launch him numerous times even last year.
# Minicamp QB Battle.
Everything points to one reality: **Shedeur wasn't winning the competition. Watson was drowning.** This is aligned with how Cleveland media has covered it. This is not to say Shedeur played badly. His growth was/is real. But it is starting to make sense why the media never just said Shedeur was winning. They said, he was just "doing better than Watson (low bar)". Even with Cleveland Media's cynicism and ineptitude, they were merely mistranslating the correct reality, but didn't have the objectiveness to see what was in front of them.
The truth is, The coaches not only prefer Watson but Watson SHOULD be outperforming Shedeur. Especially in practice environment. **So the coaches had a plan**
There was an intentionality to boosting Watsons confidence back up. You don't randomly do 7on7 red zone plays all practice with no pads for no reason. They intentionally rehabilitated his confidence and gave him opportunities to succeed. To get him out of whatever perceived slump he was in. They followed up that feel good practice with another padless practice (indoors due to weather) that the fans couldn't watch from.
**Its unironically good coaching.** Bring the best out of your players. Its just somewhat at the expense of Shedeur. Shedeur stacking 7 good days mattered less than Watson stacking 2 good days in padless practice. Those two padless practices culminated in Saturdays 1st team switcheroo.
But its a gamble. Saturday was Watsons first good padded practice, after two soft ball practices to rehabilitate his self-confidence. *What happens when we jump to live games though?*
**My Tidbit**: Some players aren't motivated by internal competition. They actively play worse under the pressure of losing their job. It's is not the same pressure as winning a football game. I think the browns felt they were somewhat handcuffing Watsons performance by having a formerly legit-ish QB competition. With the pressure of sanders removed/lessened, Watson is now throwing with confidence and starting to look as good as the coaches perceived him to be. Reports also indicate Shedeur was throwing great on Saturday with the 2s (Apparently, he played "pissed off")
I ultimately don't think this is a negative situation for any parties involved. I think Watson will practice better without Shedeur breathing down his neck. I think Shedeur will practice better now that he can focus on personal growth instead of worrying about which throw/read will take him out of Qb1 contention.
>!None of what we seen this camp has anything to do with the QB tracker. The coaches probably don't even know about those stats. Don't use it to judge the QB Battle. **I think the sole misstep, is Monken fibbing to the media** about who was with first team on saturday. I think it's possible the Sheduer wasn't told he was not going to be with the 1st that day *yet*, and Monken didn't want him to find out in a weird way. It just makes the most sense. Monken is still the straight shooter he's been marketed as. But he doesn't care about the media noise and will lie to them. Not his players. **This misstep is more so not telling Shedeur sooner**!<
Edit; Please do not get me confused. This is not an analysis of how Watson will ultimately perform in game. This is not saying, Monken has fixed Watson. This is narrowly focused on minicamp analysis. This is not an analysis of the brown's long term strategy either. Just an analysis of camp practices