SMSL R3 gaming DAC & headphone amp review
Quick feedback on the SMSL R3, well this was a surprise as I did not like the R1 much due to its interference noise and other quirks. The R3 appears to solve the issues with the R1.
The DAC side of it uses a single CS43131 (R1 uses an ES9018K2M), had to install the XMOS driver before Windows would recognise it, the default bit/sample rate is 32/48 which I left as is and let WASAPI Exclusive handle bit streaming. It appears the DSP inside it is doing good noise filtering, I noticed no interference like I did on the R1, the volume is digital so no crackling and no stepping noise during adjustment whereas R1 uses an analogue pot.
The housing looks and feels more premium than the R1 and the height of it is lower than the R1 as well, it is very aesthetically pleasing on the desk, which is not something I can usually say for gaming marketed products lol. Though here the gaming is justified as it works with PS5/Xbox etc (UAC1).
Didn't need to use the secondary USB input driving the HD490 Pro, even the USB port from my monitor was enough. Using the single ended output the 490 Pros got loud enough at around 45% volume, the L/R VU meters change to show volume level when moving the dial. Sound quality appears to be very good.
Been listening all evening and unfairly comparing it to the X8 out of curiosity (it's too late in the night to fish out the SMSL D100), it remarkably is an enjoyable sound. X8's headphone amp has a wider stereo image. Treble detail and bass appear very similar on first impression, but after a lot of back and forth it's clear the X8's headphone amp produces a more natural and detailed sound, though it is not night and day. Both DACs clearly employ the Wolfson tech CS acquired as they share a similar signature that to me feels old skool.
No distortion at higher ear-safe volumes, after 50% volume level I found it too loud to listen comfortably on the 490 Pro, and even though the specs say 68mW at 32ohm loads, the 490s at double that impedance had no trouble being driven loud without needing the extra power connection. I read some reviews on Amazon where people had 100mm planars and those absolutely need the extra power input.
Oh and the 4.4mm balanced jack is purely for convenience, both jacks have the same power.
I ordered the Topping DX1 II which is coming tomorrow so I'm quite excited to compare the two. The R3 is a very simple looking thing (in a good way), the optical out may be useful for those with active speakers that have optical input actually, so this is a selling point, though the DX1 II has balanced TRS outputs. Will update this post with DX1 II comparison tomorrow evening most likely.
Can't find an old 3.5mm mic input yet but am not expecting this side of things to be anything to write about, it's a mic input after all, though R3 does have a 48v phantom power module so beefier condenser mics etc can be used, something I don't have anyway.
Tried the EQ dials and whilst they do work, I noticed when set to all flat, toggling EQ on/off results in a noticeable drop in volume level, it feels like 5-10% level drop turning on the EQ, so you then need to compensate for that with a higher volume level. It actually feels like dynamic range slightly drops with it as well which makes sense if the DSP is having to do more work taking away resources from the output stage resulting in the drop.
Nevertheless, I actually prefer it bypassed anyway as it seems to be pretty transparent and honest to the source music, nuances aside.
I think it's a great little DAC/headphone amp that has a surprising amount of capability and deliver what I consider to be "hifi" sound.