RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/CapitalismVSocialism • … • u/Aggravating_Duck_97

Socialists are the reason socialism can't work

Yeah reading through this sub and socialists are ultimately the main reason socialism fails, after all they all do at least one of the following:

Claim "not real socialism" to the many failed attempts to make a functioning socialist society. This makes them look crazy to normal people but has the added bonus of making socialism even harder to theoretically implement since they refuse to learn from the past.

Claims to care about democracy but then say we should have vanguard parties so the people don't make the "wrong" choice.

Unironically say stuff like they should be able to kill or steal from anyone whose wealthy. Not a great look when your rhetoric for solving all the worlds problems is the exact same as the Nazi's but instead of Jews it's the rich.

Deny or downplay genocides that happened under socialist countries which makes them look like monsters to normal people.

Claims to be libertarian or peacefully supports socialism, which is logically just a lie. If you actually supported peaceful methods or non authoritarian methods of implementing socialism, you would be fine with just building worker co-ops instead of saying we should use the government to enforce it with violence.

Can't move on from Marx, the dude was an ancient racist old guy from hundreds of years ago. Even if his writings were accurate the world he wrote about no longer exists. It's 2023 not the 1800's, times change.

Actually says they support a revolution. This ones especially stupid since no ones going to actually fight a war to "destroy capitalism" or whatever when people are doing well. That's not even getting into the millions of deaths that would cause.

Flat out ignores the reality that by and large we are living in one of the most prosperous times in human history and the average person is doing great. And yes this is including people in third world countries and despite having gone through a global pandemic. I'll include said statistics on the vain hope you will actually read them.

[https://ourworldindata.org/poverty](https://ourworldindata.org/poverty)

Zero cohesion or unity, socialists historically kill each other all the time for not being pure enough or for power. Socialism is such a fragmented ideology that they will never amount to anything for the simple fact they can't agree on anything.

Speaking of not agreeing on anything, their terminology sucks since it's constantly changing and abused. Exploitation and how it's now meaningless when talking to any socialist is a prime example since it changes on practically a weekly basis. Their utter lack of any kind of ability to be consistent or coherent undermines any attempt to communicate their ideas and gain support.

Thinking that criticism of capitalism = support of socialism. No this is dumb, one system having issues does not mean it improves another. If I shoot an Olympic runner in the foot, a morbidly obese guy does not suddenly become a great runner.

Oh and finally they can't accept criticism. Just look at the comments.

— 0