RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/CapitalismVSocialism • … • u/Random_Username9105

How are nationalised economies Marxist and not capitalist?

Excuse my naivety for I am not super well-read but from my understanding, nationalized economies ultimately seem to align more with capitalism than anything. Capitalism can, I believe, be defined as a economic system where a capitalist class owns the means of production which the working class require to do work. Now, in a more nationalized economy, say USSR, there might be no or less of a private bourgeois class but practically, from the perspective of the workers, how is the state which controls the means of production any different from a capitalist class? You might argue that the state might be more incentivized to redistribute resources (while again still controlling the resources and means of production) than private capitalists but what reason is there to support that assumption? They’re still people.

Edit: to give a more practical example, consider modern day Vietnam. It’s not the most nationalized economy but there is still a degree of nationalisation and the state owns some means of production, most notably land. It’s a well known issue that politicians use this ownership to line their own pockets, such as by selling out land to foreign powers and business interests. So again, the state just seems to me like a new bourgeois with a different coat of paint.

— 0