RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/CapitalismVSocialism • … • u/coke_and_coffee

Market Socialism Can't Work

The incentive to expand production is lost.

**Traditional Capitalist Firms:**

Imagine a bakery with 10 employees that makes $1 million a year. Each baker makes $90,000, the owner gets $100,000. Because of the diminishing marginal product of labor, adding a new employee will bring in slightly less than $100,000. Hire an 11th baker, and you can bring in $95,000. No big deal, pay them market wages of $90,000 and keep an extra $5,000 in profit. Win-win-win, the owner makes a profit, the employee gets a job, and more consumers get products.

Eventually, hiring a new employee will bring in less than the market wage of $90,000 (This is self-evident and empirically robust; if this were not the case, all firms would expand infinitely. They don’t, so it is obviously true.) so the firm stops hiring. At this point, the market needs for the bakery products are satisfied.

**Worker Co-ops:**

Now imagine a co-op bakery with 10 employees that makes $1 million each year. Each employee gets $90,000 in wages and $10,000 in profit. Hiring a new employee will bring in $95,000, but because ownership must be shared equally among all employees, the $1,095,000 is now split 11 ways. That means each employee gets $90,000 in wages and $9,545 in profit.

The employees at the co-op lost money by expanding production!

This is lose-lose. The co-op doesn’t expand production and bring in more profit, the 11th baker doesn’t get a job, and there are now fewer goods made by the bakery, leading to a shortage for consumers.

This is the perverse incentives of co-ops. It’s why co-ops don’t exist at any large scale in the current economy despite being completely legal. And it’s why market socialism can’t work.

— 0