RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/CapitalismVSocialism • … • u/Attila_ze_fun

The biggest gap in communication I've faced here

Can we stop analysing countries or economies completely in isolation? Capitalism is a global system now more than ever. It makes zero sense to simply analyse historical or current economic outcomes in the global north (where an absolutely tiny minority of the world lives) and ignore everywhere else entirely when though they're part of the same global system.

Look I know capitalism supporters would say "I dont want to adopt the economic policies of haiti" and I know you don't. But the reality is that haiti is a tiny poor country completely dominated economically and politically by the West (I.e. it's a part of the broader global capitalist system), as is most of the world though that's slowly changing. The West pushes neoliberalism in every single country it can. Sometimes through direct force but mostly through soft power. Again let's not pretend capitalism is anything but a global system.

It makes no sense to compsre the USSR and the US in complete isolation when neither the USSR nor any of its allies had been dominating the markets of multiple continents or profiting off of vast networks of colonial resources unlike the countries making up the western bloc.

Its far more relevant that Canadian companies get cheap and amazingly profitable mines in the DRC than whether it's technically easy to set up a business or not in the DRC ("economic freedom" and the Sort).

—————

Please note. I'm not saying "you capitalists really want every country to become Haiti, Gotcha!!" No. I'm not doing a cheap internet gotcha moment. I'm asking you to examine your method of analysis. Please comment if I was unclear anywhere. I wrote this post while kinda sleepy but I didn't wanna risk forgetting to write this up in the morning. Apologies.

I also regret having to use Haiti and drc as negative examples. The people there deserve much better and someday I hope they get it.

—————

— 0