RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Christianity • … • u/JustToLurkArt

I’m reconsidering my definition of atheism and have some questions.

Years ago I edited my definition of atheism and basically deferred to the atheists in Reddit’s religious subs to define it.

Basically:

Atheism isn’t a belief system and identifies itself by what it is not— not theism. No rules, guidelines or ethos; no statement of belief, no methodology and no objective. It’s entirely silent on evidence or arguments.

This leaves the individual atheist to believe whatever they like for whatever reasons they want. They can believe in: ghosts, fairies, leprechauns, Bigfoot and the Loch Ness monster. They’re only a collective based solely on one matter — not a theist. The atheist can assert science and logic – or be totally unscientific and illogical, because atheism is silent on reasons and methodologies.

 

Yet a recent post got me rethinking the matter. So I re-read the [Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy](https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/). A sample/summary:

Atheism: polysemous (has multiple related meanings.) Here’s a couple:

1\. Atheism: a state of being an atheist, where an atheist is defined as someone who is not a theist.

In philosophy, however, and more specifically in the philosophy of religion:

**2\. Atheism: standardly used to refer to the proposition that God does not exist (or, more broadly, to the proposition that there are no gods).**

In 2 above it does not suffice to suspend judgment on whether there is a God, even though that implies a lack of theistic belief. Instead, one must deny that God exists. This metaphysical sense of the word is preferred over other senses, including the psychological sense, not just by theistic philosophers, but by many (though not all) atheists in philosophy as well:

* Robin Le Poidevin, “An atheist is one who denies the existence of a personal, transcendent creator of the universe, rather than one who simply lives his life without reference to such a being” (1996: xvii).

* J. L. Schellenberg, “in philosophy, the atheist is not just someone who doesn’t accept theism, but more strongly someone who opposes it.” In other words, it is “the denial of theism, the claim that there is no God” (2019: 5).

* *Concise Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy*, William L. Rowe (also an atheist), “Atheism is the position that affirms the nonexistence of God. It proposes positive disbelief rather than mere suspension of belief” (2000: 62).

* *Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy*, recognizes multiple senses of the word “atheism”, but is clear about which is standard in philosophy: [Atheism is] the view that there are no gods. A widely used sense denotes merely not believing in god and is consistent with agnosticism [in the psychological sense]. A stricter sense denotes a belief that there is no god; this use has become standard. (Pojman 2015, emphasis added)

* *Encyclopedia of Philosophy*, broadens the standard definition of “atheist” but still requires rejection of belief in God as opposed to merely lacking that belief.

* *Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy*: an atheist is a person who rejects belief in God, regardless of whether or not the reason for the rejection is the claim that “God exists” expresses a false proposition. People frequently adopt an attitude of rejection toward a position for reasons other than that it is a false proposition.

 

The standard metaphysical definition of “atheism” in item 2 above is especially useful for philosophy.

It has the virtue of making atheism a direct answer to one of the most important metaphysical questions in philosophy of religion, namely, “Does God exist?” There are only two possible direct answers to this question: “yes”, which is theism, and “no”, which is atheism

Answers like “I don’t know” or “I’m not convinced” are passive and not direct answers to this question. It is useful for philosophers to have a good name for this important metaphysical position, and “atheism” works beautifully for that purpose.

(**Note:** There’s already a term for people who lack theistic belief = “nontheist”. The term “atheist” is not needed for that purpose.)

Defining “atheism” as the state of deficiency or lacking is problematic because it needs to be expanded to avoid the problematic issue of babies, cats, and rocks et al counting as atheists by virtue of lacking belief in God.

An additional problem arises because one can lack belief in God while at the same time having other pro-attitudes towards theism aka Christian atheist. While such people should not be labeled theists, it is counterintuitive in the extreme to call them atheists. The psychological definition also makes atheists out of some people who are devoted members (at least in terms of practice) of theistic religious communities. This is because, as is well-known, some devoted members of such communities have only a vague middling level of confidence that God exists and no belief that God exists or even that God probably exists. It would seem misguided for philosophers to classify such people as atheists.

 

**Question:**

1\. If you so simply lack belief, why don’t you use a term better suited that already exists aka “nontheist”?

2\. Why not eliminate ambiguity to define atheism as the proposition that God does not exist (or, more broadly, to the proposition that there are no gods)?

Thanks.

— 0