What do you guys think about Alan Gewerth's attempt to justify objective morality without the divine ?
His argument is something like this:
All action has a goal: Whenever you act voluntarily, you do so to achieve a goal you consider valuable.
Action requires basic conditions: You cannot pursue any goal without freedom (agency) and well-being (life, health, physical integrity). Gewirth calls these generic goods.
You must claim a right to these conditions: Because you need freedom and well-being to act, you logically must insist that others do not interfere with them. You are committed to the claim: "I have a right to freedom and well-being."
The claim is based solely on agency: You make this claim simply because you are an acting, goal-directed agent—not because of your special identity, wealth, or status.
Universalization is logically required: By standard rules of logic, if you claim rights simply because you are an acting agent, you must grant those exact same rights to all other acting agents.
Moral duty follows: Respecting others' rights to freedom and well-being is not a subjective preference—it is a logical requirement.
(Summarized by Gemini, hence the em dashes)
It's an argument that behaving immorally is also an action of irrationality.
That's not to say that people can't behave immorally under this system (em dash) they absolutely can, it's just an argument that they would be in violation of reason if they chose to do that.