RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/CrusaderKings • … • u/TarnishedSteel

CK3 lacks imagination! It’s somehow both too ahistorical and too attached to history

My biggest gripe with CK3 as it stands is that, for a game that starts in the 9th century, its focus is still on what the world would become, rather than letting a player’s imagination and the random hand of fate play out.

There are understandable reasons for some of this—the devs can’t come up with entirely new sports that could have emerged instead of jousting, for example. My pet peeve, though, is that some counties, duchies, and kingdoms are just better than others, and not necessarily for any historic or balancing reason. If you’ve been in the sub for a while, you’ve probably seen Ivory Tower Bohemia runs where a player can develop the kingdom into a utopia.

Land type, special building presence, and the size of holdings in terms of maximum holdings per county and de jure size of duchies and kingdoms have huge, static effects, and of those, only duchy and kingdom de jure ownership can be shifted, and then only after a great deal of time has passed. Wards and Wardens only served to highlight this, since the university visit feature is exclusive to universities and cathedrals, which can only be founded in historical locations. This contributes, in my opinion, to runs feeling same-y and poisoning replay value.

So, is there anything that could be done about this? Of course. CK2 had modular, ahistorical monument construction, allowing historical monuments to lead the way for player-led construction. There‘s no reason that we couldn’t have that back, in some limited fashion. Farmlands and large counties tend to exist in CK3 where historical cities tended to emerge, but investment and patience should allow players to establish new metropoli (though perhaps not on the tops of mountains or in the bitterest north, without some culture or technology). De jure ownership of counties currently exists to make Europe more stable and avoid abuses like North Korea mode, but custom kingdoms are hardly breaking the game as it stands. The ability to reconfigure duchies or kingdom titles should absolutely be part of the base game, with limits on grouping noncontiguous counties, or those of different cultures and religions, and at the cost of prestige, time, or tyranny.

These features could lead to play-throughs of the game becoming more truly unique, without the specter of having to relocate your capital to that one farmland county the devs liked best so you can have the best buildings, or needing to conquer a whole extra Kingdom to see the new university feature. These changes would also be more true to the history of the era, where the political geography and demographics of Eurasia were in flux, with power centers emerging and falling as the centuries passed.

— 0