Josh Brolin as Carls Dad if we cant get Patrick.
So carl is 27, and his dad was around his age when he left from what we can tell in the books. Josh Brolin is currently 58, and looks damn good still might i add. He can act tf out of a role, and he has played pos dad's and people like Carl's dad before. Therefore I proclaim that if we cant get Patrick Warburton in a live action, he is my next top pick.