RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DMAcademy • … • u/funktasticdog

Give your players a Free Expertise, or the Best Grappler is... a Lore Bard

Right now, in 5e, skills are busted in a way that isn't entirely obvious until you play the game wrong. People think that big, hulking goliaths like the Barbarian, for instance, would make for the best grappler, pinning down opponents with their hulking strength, or the Monk, who's expertise in martial arts makes them excellent at it. And they're not bad, for sure... but they're not the best.

The Bard is the best grappler, by a pretty big margin. A lore bard gets cutting words, which lets them reduce the ability check for any opponent they're grappling. On it's own that's pretty good... but what makes them excellent is their expertise, which they can put into athletics. Now not only are they the best grapplers, but whenever someone needs something lifted, instead of going to the hulking slab of muscles... they'd go to the Bard.

But the problem isn't just with Bards, Rogues, and now Rangers being better than everyone else at grappling, it extends to literally every other skill. A Rogue can always be better than a druid would ever be at nature checks, a bard could always be better than a monk would ever be at acrobatics check, a ranger could always be better at a wizard at arcana checks.

Sure they likely wouldn't do this, but they very well might put their expertise in acrobatics, which makes playing the nimble, high flying, acrobatic monk a little lame when the showboat bard can always do it better than you. Yes, they could take the new skill expert, but they shouldn't have to give up an ASI to do what the flavour of their class says they can do.

Thankfully, there's an easy solution, and one with very little power creep.

At character creation, give **all** your players a free expertise in one skill of their choice.

This lets your players fulfill the fantasy of their class easily when they would otherwise not get to. Now, the wizard really *does* know the most about the cosmos, the druid really *is* the most in touch with nature, and the barbarian and monks really are the best grapplers. The beauty of this is that you give *all* your players a free expertise, than the rogues, bards and rangers don't feel their toes stepped on, because they also get an extra thing they're really really good at.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.

— 0