Christianity caused extraordinary global harm
Premise 1: Harm caused by an ideology includes not only direct killing, but also the destruction of cultures, religions, languages, families, and peoples.
Premise 2: Major Christian churches, leaders, and followers have repeatedly allied themselves with state and imperial authorities in projects of conquest, colonialism, forced conversion, and coercive assimilation for roughly 1,700 years.
Premise 3: During that time, Christian institutions repeatedly participated in conquest, forced conversion, suppression of Indigenous religions, destruction of sacred sites, child-removal policies, and campaigns of cultural assimilation across Europe, the Americas, Africa, Asia, and Australia.
Premise 4: These actions caused lasting harm to millions of people by destroying or attempting to destroy their traditional identities, languages, religions, and social structures, even where mass killing was not the primary objective.
Premise 5: Political, economic, and colonial motives also contributed to these harms. Nevertheless, Christian institutions were often active participants and frequently supplied the moral justification for replacing non-Christian cultures with Christian ones.
Premise 6: These harms weren’t confined to one branch of Christianity. Catholic and Protestant institutions both participated in colonial expansion, suppression of Indigenous religions and languages, coercive assimilation, missionary schooling, and the removal of children from their families. The specific institutions and methods varied, but the underlying pattern crossed denominational lines.
Conclusion: Therefore, Christianity has been one of history's most significant contributors to long-term human harm through cultural destruction and forced assimilation, and its historical record cannot reasonably be dismissed by pointing only to twentieth-century dictators such as Mao or Stalin.