RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAChristian • … • u/Aggravating_Olive_70

Adding Satan into Gen 3 creates irreconcilable contradictions

Gen 3 introduces the serpent as "more crafty than any beast of the field that Yahweh God had made."

Some Christian interpretations assert the serpent is either 1) Satan, 2) Satan disguised as a serpent, or 3) a serpent used by Satan.

P1: Gen identifies it as the serpent, one of the animals Yahweh made.

P2: After the fall Yahweh talks to the serpent directly. Its curse consists of serpent-specific punishments:

crawling on its belly,

eating dust,

enmity between the "serpent's offspring and the woman's offspring"

P3: Genesis describes the serpent as crafty, not as in league with a supernatural being.

P4: The serpent's statements aren't shown in the narrative to be false; instead, their eyes are opened, and Yahweh acknowledges humans "now know good and evil."

P5: If the serpent is Satan, then some of these must be true:

• Yahweh knowingly addresses Satan an animal and Yahweh’s curses for Satan are animal, not angel, punishments.

• Yahweh wrongly condemns an innocent species of animals for Satan's actions

• Yahweh fails to recognize one of its own angels, fooled into thinking it was an animal.

C: Occam's Razor. None of these contradictions come up if Gen is read as describing exactly what it says: Yahweh interacting with the serpent previously identified in the narrative.

— 0