RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAChristian • … • u/Aggravating_Olive_70

Paul, not Jesus, created the Christian religion

Paul transformed a Jewish sect into a new Gentile religion.

**Premise 1:** Jesus’ ministry operated entirely within the rules of Judaism. Jesus was Jewish. His disciples were Jewish. He preached in synagogues, cited the Torah and prophets, attended Jewish festivals and debated with other Jews over correct interpretation of Jewish law.

The twelve disciples symbolically invoked the twelve tribes of Israel. His message concerned Israel’s god, Israel’s covenant, Israel’s Messiah and the coming kingdom of his god.

"God-fearers" were monothestic Gentiles who rejected circumcistion but could interact with Jewish synagogues and worship of Israel’s god.

**Premise 2:** Jesus had occasional interactions with non-Jews yet he never establishes a pagan-compatible version of his ministry for Gentiles, nor does he include any gentiles in his movement, nor ask them to convert.

The Syrophoenician woman and the Roman centurion received assistance, but neither episode creates means by which Jesus teaches pagans how they could join god’s people sans circumcision or Torah observance.

Instead, Jesus explicitly says he was sent to the lost sheep of Israel.

**Premise 3:** After Jesus’ execution, his original followers continued as a Jewish sect based in Jerusalem.

The church Pillars were James( the brother of Jesus), Peter and John. They establish their headquarters in Jerusalem. Had they been teaching that Jesus was the god of Isreal, they would have never been allowed to stay. Instead the Jesus movement was accepted by Jews as a new Jewish sect.

"Brother, you see how many thousands of Jews have become believers, and all of them keep the Law" -Acts 21:20

Acts depicts them attending the Temple, praying at Jewish hours of prayer and living among other Jews. The movement was called “the sect of the Nazarenes.” Judaism has a tradition of having sects that disagree profoundly while remaining recognisably Jewish. The early Jesus movement within that sectarian landscape.

**Premise 4:** The Jerusalem church remained Torah-observant after Jesus’ death. James is quoted as having concerned about reports that Paul teaches Jews living among Gentiles to abandon Moses, stop circumcising their children and reject Jewish customs.

James order Paul to undergo purification and publicly demonstrate that he continues to observe the Law.

\[To Paul\] "Take these men, join in their purification rites and pay their expenses, so that they can have their heads shaved. Then everyone will know there is no truth in these reports about you, but that you yourself are living in obedience to the law."

And Paul complies.

**Premise 5:** Josephus independently places James inside the institutional and political world of Jerusalem Judaism. Josephus identifies James as the brother of Jesus who was called Christ.

He records how James was brought before a Sanhedrin convened by the high priest and accused of violating Jewish law. Other influential Jews object to the high priest’s conduct. When James is executed, those same influential Jewish men work to get the high priest who killed James removed. This is evidence outside the Bible that the Jesus movement was not rejected by Jewish people. This would be impossible had the JM been preaching that Jesus was god and the Law was no longer needed.

**Premise 6:** There’s no surviving evidence that Jesus taught his disciples to abolish circumcision, food boundaries or Torah observance.

Jesus never tells Jewish followers they shouldn't circumcise their children. He never announces that pagan converts could enter his god’s covenant without converting. There’s no of Jesus telling his followers it was fine for Jews to eat alongside uncircumcised Gentile believers.

Those controversies only emerge years after Jesus's execution and with the arrival of Paul and his pagan converts..

**Premise 7:** The major boundary conflicts began when Paul recruited uncircumcised Gentiles.

Paul’s preaching to gentiles that they could be part of the Jewish kingdom of heaven forced the Pillars to create policies on issues the Jesus movement hadn’t previously confronted:

Must Gentile men be circumcised? Must they convert to Judaism? Can Torah-observant Jews eat with them? What rules of purity and food apply? Can Gentiles become descendants of Abraham without adopting the covenantal sign given to Abraham?

Acts portrays Peter, one of the Pillars(!), as needing extraordinary divine intervention before he entered an uncircumcised Gentile’s home. That makes no sense if Jesus in his lifetime taught a Torah-free Gentile gospel.

**Premise 8:** Paul admits that his gospel didn’t come from Jesus’ original disciples.

We all know Paul converted years after Jesus's death. In Gal, he insists that he didn’t receive his gospel from human beings. He received it through "revelation".

So Paul’s theology a completely different set of teachings than the ones preached by the men who followed Jesus in his life and carried on his work after his death.

**Premise 9:** Paul’s theology is unconncted to anything Jesus is depicted as saying in the gospels.

Jesus’ teachings are strictily with ideas at the time about the kingdom of their god, repentance, Israel, the Torah and the prophets.

Paul builds an entirely new and universal theology around Adam and Christ.

Adam introduces sin and death, then the messiah reverses Adam. Participation in Christ creates a new humanity. Gentiles become children of Abraham through faith not circumcision. Christ’s death and resurrection become the basis for admitting pagans into God’s people skipping over full Torah observance.

That’s a sophisticated theological system. But where did Jesus teach it?

Where in the gospels does Jesus explain that his death would replace circumcision and observance of the Law? His followers after death keep the Law.

Where in the gospels does did Jesus say that uncircumcised pagans could become Abraham’s descendants merely by declaring they believed in his resurrection?

Where did Jesus present himself as a second Adam?

These are Pauline arguments, not the teachings of Jesus.

**Conclusion:**

The earliest Jesus movement was a Torah-observant Jewish sect based in Jerusalem, led by observant Jews and accepted as a sect within Judaism.

Disputes over circumcision, food and Jewish-Gentile relations appear only after Paul unilaterally decides he uncircumcised pagans get the same benefits of the Convenant as observant Jews.

Paul transforming a Jewish messianic sect into a new transethnic movement built around his own theology of Adam, Christ, faith and the Law. There's nothing in the words attributed to Jesus that indicate he would have recognised Paul’s new religion as what he'd preached.

— 0