Title: Given the truth of Bible-believing Christianity, Stomping on a Baby’s Skull is not an Intrinsically Evil Act.
**Title: Given the truth of Bible-believing Christianity, Stomping on a Baby’s Skull is not an Intrinsically Evil Act.**
**Thesis: If you are a Bible believing Christian, you must hold the position that stomping on a living baby’s skull is not an intrinsically evil act, but at very worst a morally neutral act.**
**Terms**: For this argument God will refer to the God of the Christian Bible, and the Christian Bible is assumed to be inerrant and correctly translated.
**Intrinsically:** I take intrinsically to mean a concept being considered entirely by and of itself. To give an example: walking through a door is not an intrinsically evil act. However, if someone else owns the home, and forbids on pain of trespass the transiting of their door, then the act becomes evil on virtue of the added stipulations. Walking through a door, on its own, remains intrinsically morally neutral.
P1. God cannot condone an act which is intrinsically evil
P2. God condones stepping on baby skulls
C. Stepping on baby skulls is not intrinsically evil
I don’t think I need to defend P1. to a Christian, but here’s some verses.
Psalm 5:4 (ESV) *For you are not a God who delights in wickedness;*
*evil may not dwell with you.*
*5 The boastful shall not stand before your eyes;*
*you hate all evildoers.*
*6 You destroy those who speak lies;*
*the Lord abhors the bloodthirsty and deceitful man.*
Habakkuk 1:13 (NRSVUE)*Your eyes are too pure to behold evil,*
*and you cannot look on wrongdoing;*
*why do you look on the treacherous*
*and are silent when the wicked swallow*
*those more righteous than they?*
In defense of P2:
P2a. God orders babies to be killed multiple times in the Bible.
P2b. Since God does not specify which method should be used to kill said babies, any reasonable method can be inferred.
Therefore P2: God condones stepping on baby skulls.
In defense of P2a:
Numbers 31:17 (NRSVUE):*Now therefore, kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman who has known a man by sleeping with him. 18 But all the young girls who have not known a man by sleeping with him, keep alive for yourselves.*
‘Every Male among the little ones’ would include babies.
1 Samuel 15:3 (NIV) *Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.*
Deuteronomy 20:16 (NRSVUE) *But as for the towns of these peoples that the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, you must not let anything that breathes remain alive.*
In defense of P2b:
Given that an outcome is expected, we should not make assumptions about how that outcome is reached. For example, if a judge finds a man guilty of murder and sentences him to execution, we are not then permitted to
\-Keelhaul him
\-Beat him to death with hammers
\-throw him off a really tall building
Yes the judge has ordered the *end result* of an execution, but reasonable action should be expected to carry out the sentence. Anything extra would be needless cruelty.
Without any concept of what that method was in the verbiage of God’s order, those executing the order must make assumptions given the nature of the judge. The assumption can be made that God would want the infant killed quickly and painlessly, which to a spear-wielding Israelite would mean, potentially, immediate and lethal blunt force. Therefore: Boot to the baby!
**Possible objections:**
**1. Killing babies is only moral if divinely commanded.**
Counterpoint: If the morality of an act changes based on who commits the act, then the act itself is not *intrinsically* morally ordered. That moral quality is derived extrinsically. If you want to argue that God gave life to babies and therefore has the right to take away life from the babies, you must fully and completely concede the end point of my argument: That stepping on baby skulls is not intrinsically evil. Rather, the evil in question depends on with whom the command or action originates.
This means that the act (baby skull stomping) is therefore not intrinsically evil within itself. This counterargument is a full concession of my thesis statement.
**2. Those babies deserved it**
I fully concede. If you think babies sometimes commit or possibly inherit sin such that they deserve to have their skulls caved in, I don’t have any way to change your mind.
**3: Your “Atheist” worldview can't account for why stomping baby skulls is evil either.**
While I don't agree, the conversation on my morals is a very long one and a blatant diversion. I'll grant this Tu Quoque fallacy for the sake of argument. I can't condemn baby skulls smashing as being intrinsically evil. But neither can Bible-believing Christians.
**4. The Israelites butchering those babies were executing a divine judgement. Without the method given by God, it does not follow that a specific method was used.**
Granted. I amend my argument to your preferred method. Which do you prefer: axe, sword, strangulation, dashed the babies against rocks head-first?
**Conclusion / Disclaimer:** **The argument is not intended to disprove the existence of God or the truth of the Bible. The argument is intended to arrive at the conclusion exactly as laid out in the thesis: Given the truth of Bible-believing Christianity, Stomping on a Baby’s Skull is not an Intrinsically Evil Act.**
In actual fact, this argument needs to stand as part of a larger argument I’m working on as a critique of the second premise of Bill Craig’s famous ‘Moral Argument’ for the existence of God. His argument, quoted from memory:
P1: Objective moral values and duties do not exist without God.
P2: Objective moral values and duties do exist.
C: God exists.