RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAChristian • … • u/LCDRformat

The Bible-believing Christian is logically committed to the belief that everyone who is not a Bible-believing Christian is stupid.

**The Bible-believing Christian is logically committed to the position that every rational agent who is not a Bible-believing Christian is stupid.**

**Terms**: For this argument ‘God’ will refer to the God of the Christian Bible.

The Christian Bible is assumed to be the word of God and correctly translated.

‘Rejecting God’ as an action is assumed to result in some sort of suffering - be that little red guys with pitchforks waterboarding you for eternity, or simply a self-selected separation from God, who is the source of all Goodness, Joy, Love, etc.

‘Stupid’ is taken to mean ***both*** of two possible definitions: 1: Lacking intelligence, common sense, or good judgment 2: Knowingly choosing an action which results in an objectively worse outcome, for the self and/or for others.

‘Anyone’ refers to all rational agents, that is some person who takes actions with motivation towards goals, and is of sound/logical mind. **I want to be clear that I am specifically not referring to disabled people or people otherwise incapable of making rational decisions.** ‘Anyone’ exclusively refers to agents capable of making their own informed choices.

My argument:

**1.** **God has sufficiently demonstrated the truth of his word to all rational agents such that anyone who rejects him does so with full knowledge and without excuse.**

**2. God is the source of all joy, love, and goodness, and rejecting him leads to the maximal amount of suffering and misery for all of eternity.**

**3. Anyone who is in a state of failing to accept God is in a state of actively rejecting him**

**-(Sub-conclusion: Every non-Christian is knowingly choosing to live in eternal suffering and misery).**

**4. Anyone who knowingly chooses to live in the maximal amount of suffering and misery for all eternity over maximal goodness is a stupid person by virtue of making the stupidest decision possible.**

**C. Therefore, the Bible-believing Christian is logically committed to the belief that every rational agent who is not a Bible-believing Christian is stupid.**

**Motivation for P1:** Let’s take a look at some verses to motivate the idea that **God has sufficiently demonstrated the truth of his word to all thinking agents such that they may choose him of their own free will.**

**Biblical citations for P1:**

Romans 1, too long to paste in its entirety, but the key portion: Romans 1:19 *For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. Ever since the creation of the world God’s eternal power and divine nature, invisible though they are, have been seen and understood through the things God has made. So they are without excuse, for though they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their senseless hearts were darkened. Claiming to be wise, they became fools…*

Paul says that the truth of God is obvious and known to everyone.

John 3:18 *Those who believe in him are not condemned, but those who do not believe are condemned already because they have not believed in the name of the only Son of God.* ^(19) *And this is the judgment, that the light has come into the world, and people loved darkness rather than light because their deeds were evil.* ^(20) *For all who do evil hate the light and do not come to the light, so that their deeds may not be exposed.* ^(21) *But those who do what is true come to the light,*

Jesus describes the people who come into the light as ‘doing what is true’ and the people who do evil choosing to do evil because they love darkness.

**Rational argument for P1:**

Rejection of P1 leads to serious theological problems. The negation of P1 being “**God has** ***not*** **sufficiently demonstrated the truth of his word…”**

1 Timothy 2:3  *This is right and acceptable before God our Savior,* ^(4) *who desires everyone to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.*

If God wants all people to come to the truth, then God *not* sufficiently demonstrating the truth of his word represents a failure on God’s part. I assert that this premise will remain uncontroversial in light of God’s infallibility, accepted by all Christians. God cannot fail to achieve a goal.

**Motivations for P2:**

God is the source of all joy, love, and goodness, and rejecting him leads to the maximal amount of suffering and misery for all of eternity. I assume the first portion of the premise will remain uncontroversial amongst Christians, and given my lax definition of rejecting God (‘some sort of suffering - be that little red guys with pitchforks waterboarding you for eternity, or simply a self-selected separation from God, who is the source of all Goodness, Joy, Love, etc.’), I expect the second half to be uncontroversial amongst both ECT believers and those who believe that Hell is merely ‘separation’ from the source of Goodness, peace, and joy. I am asserting that being cut off from all love, peace, and joy for all eternity would be absolutely \*\*wretched and miserable.\*\*

The only groups of Christians my premise fails on are the universalists and annihilationists. I’m not debating universalists in this post. Some verses: Matthew 8:12, Jesus describes hell as a place of ‘weeping and gnashing of teeth’, Matthew 25:41 Jesus compares hell to an eternal fire, Matthew 25:46, I don't know if you need more verses about this I think there’s one in Revelation? ‘Rejecting God will be miserable’ is my assertion, whether you believe in ECT or just separation from the source of all love, joy, and goodness. If you still think this isn’t the case, I concede the argument does not apply to you.

Annihilationists can possibly wriggle out of this post by saying it’s not stupid to choose to die instead of being in the presence of God. I’ll be interested in speaking to this more in the comments.

**Motivation for Premise** **3:**

**Anyone who is in a state of failing to accept God is in a state of actively rejecting him.**

Firstly, there is no neutral ground with Christianity. After being accused of driving out demons in the name of Satan, Jesus said: (Matthew 12:30, NRSVUE) *“Whoever is not with me is against me, and whoever does not gather with me scatters.”*

In Romans 1, Paul explains that everyone who rejects God is suppressing the truth in their unrighteousness. Romans 1:18 *For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and injustice of those who by their injustice suppress the truth. For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them.*

Indicating that everyone knows the truth of Christianity, some just choose to ignore that truth to profit from their own unjust selfishness.

**Motivations for P4:**

**Anyone who knowingly chooses to live in the maximum amount of suffering and misery for all eternity is a stupid person by virtue of making the stupidest decision possible.**

For this, you may refer to my dual definitions of stupid:

1: Lacking intelligence, common sense, or good judgment 2: Knowingly choosing an action which results in an objectively worse outcome, for the self and/or for others.

Unless you contest these definitions, the following argument is irrefutable:

1. Knowingly choosing to live in the maximal amount of suffering and misery for all eternity is choosing the objectively **worst** **outcome** for the self 2. Anyone who knowingly chooses the objectively worst outcome for the self meets the definition of stupid

C. Therefore, anyone who knowingly chooses to live in the maximal amount of suffering and misery for all eternity is stupid.

**Lastly:**

**Psalms 53:** *Fools say in their hearts, “There is no God.”* *They are corrupt; they commit abominable acts;* *there is no one who does good.*

^(2) *God looks down from heaven on humankind* *to see if there are any who are wise,* *who seek after God.*

The Psalmist agrees with me.

**Possible Objections:**

1. Not everyone who rejects God knows about him.

So yeah, you could say this, you could argue against the Bible verses I’ve presented above, or my interpretation of them. But do you really want to? If people are rejecting God, either because they’ve never heard of him, or perhaps they didn’t quite read the fine print, then it follows: God is not good. Condemning people to ECT or separation or whatever agony you want to name, without fully informing them of what they’re doing is cruel and senseless.

David Platt argues in his ‘Secret Church’ sermon on Heaven and hell that unreached people are condemned to Hell because of their inherent sinfulness, not because they failed to hear the Gospel. He argues that \*\*ALL\*\* have fallen short of the glory of God, and therefore even those who have never heard burn for eternity. Remember, in Romans 1 Paul explains that these people are without excuse.

If you want to watch him explain this in the sermon that started my deconversion, you can do so\[ here\](https://youtu.be/z0YhuFjMXXQ?si=iJRiM3ffPk0hmhxv). I would counter that it’s unjust - by definition of the word - to offer salvation to some sinners and withhold it from others. In the interest of time I’ll save this argument for the comments if you choose to have it.

Or perhaps you may say: Those rational agents who lack sufficient information to make a decision on this are not condemned, and are instead permitted into Heaven on their death.

I think the theological implications of that will be more serious for your fellow Christians, because Jesus says he is the way the truth and the light, and no one comes through the father except through him. I didn’t pull up the citation for this, but it’s in the gospels somewhere. If people can receive salvation without choosing Christ, then the resurrection was meaningless. The cross has no power. I don’t think that’s an acceptable position for a Christian.

— 0