RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAChristian • … • u/LTEDan

Free will is not a solution to the problem of evil

I've seen plenty of Christians asseet that free will is the source of evil in the universe. However, God's omniscinecence and omnipotence means regardless of our free will he knows the outcomes of our choices since before creation and could have created us differently such that we didn't freely choose sin, but deliberatly created us this way anyway.

I'll use weather forecasting as an example with God's omniscience. Our weather forecasting ability breaks down after a week, and the resolution is low enough you'll never know if you're getting rain at your house or not, we just get a general idea of what to expect in our area a few days ahead. The reason predicting the weather is hard is we have an imperfect knowledge of the initial conditions, and weather forecasting is extremely sensitive to the initial conditions. A small difference leads to vastly different weather predictions.

For an omniscient being like God, though, predicting the weather would be child's play because that being would have perfect knowledge of the initial conditions and perhaps even many more variables than our forecasts can account for. Plus that being's resolution is as high as it goes. God would know where every single raindrop will land, where every lighting bolt will strike and where every wind gust will form. If a person causes a mass firestorm that alters the local weather, this is already known and accounted for in God's forecasts as well.

We can easily see how the large amount of variables and imperfect initial conditions messes with our weather forecasting abilities when we compare it to, say, solar and lunar eclipses. Because there's far fewer variables involved with orbiting bodies we can predict solar and lunar eclipses up to 35,000 years into the future with a +/- 24 hour accuracy. Compare that to weather which is really only accurate a few days out and anything beyond 7 days is a guess.

So back to our free will. If God gives us the ability to make whatever choice we want, he already knows what choice we will make for every single action of our entire lifetime, as well as every variable that led to us making those choices. He has to know this if he's omniscient.

The problem comes in when you add in his omnipotence. God isn't like us humans predicting the weather, at the mercy of the weather, powerless to change it and simply able to predict the weather before it happens. No, God created everything which includes the initial conditions that leads to a hurricane, or that leads us to choose sin. So even if we have the free will to choose sin, God was the one that created the universe in such a way where we would choose to sin instead of not sin.

In essence, an omnipotent and omniscient being would be able to know the final outcome of the initial conditions of the entirety of his creation. He'd know who rejected him and why. He'd be able to simulate infinite universes with infinite variations on the initial conditions as well as the final outcome of each of those universes with his imagination alone. With infinite possibilities, surely there was at least one set of initial conditions that lead to no sin. The fact that we're here now with free will and sin is a direct result of the universe God deliberately created, knowing who will sin, when, and why, so the problem of evil is still a problem even with free will.

Was God's creation really that perfect, then? I can imagine a more perfect creation. One that is exactly like the one he created except it isn't corruptible. It was corrupted with evil because allowed it to be, regardless of our free will.

— 0