RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAVegan • … • u/Chembaron_Seki

Animals as moral agents

One argument that pops up quite often in the debate about veganism is that carnists often don't understand why it is morally acceptable for animals to eat/exploit other animals, but it isn't for humans.

The argument vegans use against that is usually that animals are not moral agents. To be frank, I don't think that is really true.

If animals are not moral agents and therefore don't make decisions on concepts as right or wrong, then why do we see true altruism happen in nature?

Like how a hippo was observed saving a young zebra that was getting separated from the herd when they crossed a river. There was no benefit for the hippo in doing that. It was actually detrimental for it, because it was spending energy by doing something that would give no positive return for it.

Or if animals are adopting the children of another species. They could just let them die in the wild, why do the labor of taking care for them?

There was even a case of a mother lion who lost her cubs and then adopted a young antelope. That lioness even went as far as not eating for the time it took care of the antelope. Just when the gazelle got killed by another lion, she went back to eating meat.

Over time, we notice that animals are more similar to us than we expected. Why should they not have some concept of what is right and wrong to do? Some things done by animals make me think that they actually do have these concepts.

— 0