RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAVegan • … • u/No-Weird-5784

Emotional wellbeing as an argument against veganism

So I'm Chinese American and I grew up in an Asian hub in the US where meat dishes from me and my friends' cultures had some significance to us in terms of staying connected to our respective cultures. I say meat dishes here because almost all of the 300 Chinese dishes I can name have at least trace amounts of meat (for instance, even in vegetable stir fries we add dried shrimp or oyster sauce). I'm now in the UK for school and I'm meeting vegan people for the first time so I've recently been thinking about the morals involved.

The problem is, whenever I pick the vegan option for a meal, it genuinely makes me depressed and unproductive for the rest of the day. Like after lunch I sit down in the library for my 1pm-6pm lock in session and the whole time I'm lowkey wishing I picked the meat option... I think it's because it tastes better and also reminds me of home. Another example - I tried mixing the matcha powder I brought from home with plant-based milks and I crashed out so hard I'm writing this post, lmao.

So in my opinion. Eating meat, for me, isn't just a 'fleeting pleasure'... it genuinely impacts my emotional wellbeing. And I would value the emotional wellbeing of a human over an animal's suffering. Like lowkey I would imprison and overfeed a chicken for my friend to be happier for a month.

Actually I would argue that most people value humans' emotional wellbeing just as highly. For instance, I think having children is highly immoral because you spend maybe $300k-500k raising them. Peter Singer would lowkey argue that it takes $3-5k to save a life, and while you might disagree with the amount/disagree with giving it to charity, you can't deny that $300k-500k would probably save a good number of lives. And yet we value the emotional wellbeing of a couple/their family over the suffering of, like, 100 people, and I even think this is valid, because emotional wellbeing IS that important.

So it sort of upsets me when vegans think all non-vegans are either 'living in ignorance' or 'unethical at heart' because although some definitely are, I also think there's line to be drawn here for the amount of suffering you'll tolerate for a human's emotional wellbeing. And I think when people say shit like "but I love bacon!" they're really expressing this argument (though articulated terribly).

Curious to hear your thoughts!

— 0