RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateAnAtheist • … • u/KnodiChunks

Being welcoming to weak arguments

I understand how frustrating it is when a theist comes in just to kick the anthill, toss off a flippant question, ignore the hard answers, and then spew fallacies in response to the few questions they think they've got a canned response for.

Believe me, I feel frustrated by that too.

But this subreddit is going to die off if it becomes standard that every theist who posts in here must first sacrifice several hundred points of karma to the anger and frustration of the atheists.

Sometimes answering fallacies with patience and clarity makes a difference. But it can't work if the person we're responding to is being downvoted into oblivion, or angrily insulted.

May I make a couple of suggestions? What if we remove our downvote button, and agree to *try* not to suppress subreddit styles and downvote anyway? If you are too angry to respond to a theist politely, then maybe just don't reply? I **know** how satisfying it is to dogpile on a fallacy or make smug quips, but in the end, this is a place for **theists** to come and debate with **atheists**. I know most of their arguments are hollow and fallacious, but they're *why we are here*.

In lieu of a snide, hurtful comment, or even a downvote, maybe a more effective thing to do would be to post a permalink to the well-reasoned post that we'd most like to see them try and answer? Doing this isn't going to give you the same feeling of "so there!", but it is the approach **most** likely to generate a meaningful discussion that can educate and change minds.

— 0