We're going about the religion debate all wrong. God is not a conclusion; God is an intuition. We're working from logic, and objective evidence, and we're consciously thinking about it, while theists are working from intuition. Silly us.
We (most of us anyway, I exempt myself and a couple others I know of) expect theists to ask, as we do, "what's the evidence" and set their conscious, thinking mind to work in order to come to a conclusion on the question of gods. You know that old saying, that you can't logic someone out of a position they didn't get to by logic? With believers, god is not a conclusion - for them god is an intuition. We all examine the evidence and arguments to make the best factual determination we can. They use the evidence and arguments to prove that their intuition is correct. Acquinas didn't start with a philosophical examination of what motion, causation, or contingency tell us about the world. Acquinas started with his intuition then crafted those arguments to support that his intuition of God is correct. ("Always trust your intuition, go with your gut feeling," is the worst advice ever.)
Most of you baby raping nun eating atheists (or are we nun rapers and baby eaters? So easy to get that backwards) have said you were believers at one point. If that ain't you, please pretend it is you for a while. You didn't believe in whatever deity was big in your locale for anything like evidentiary reasons, things that are evaluated through active conscious thought. You were told about it and if you are like most, you didn't question it at all. It was intuitively apparent, once it was explained.
I never believed in god but I can remember a time when I believed in Santa and the tooth fairy. If I had spent any effort at thinking about how there's this fairy thing (and what is a fairy exactly anyway?) that takes my tooth away and leaves a dime (hey, I'm older than dirt) I would have had a number of questions. Why does it want my tooth and what does it do with it? How does it know to come to my bedroom - does it come every night or only after a tooth comes out? If the house is sealed up tighter than (not that a child would use this metaphor) a Qanonsenser's butthole,what does it do? How does it carry the tooth, especially if the only way in or our is via tiny openings? But of course none of us gave the tooth fairy a moment's thought. Mom said it and it was intuitively satisfying.
Had I given any active thought to Santa, I would have had a number of very difficult questions. How does he fit presents for every boy and girl in the whole world in that little sleigh? How does he get into places that have no chimney? How does he cover the entire world in just a few hours? How does he know when I've been sleeping or awake? And so on. But five year old me didn't give one iota of throught to those kind of things. No I just listened to my mom, with wide eyes. I never really _thought about _ (not _of_, _about_) Santa. The Santa I was told about was intuitively satisfying.
Cognitive psychologist Debora Kelemen proposes that children are intuitive theists - disposed to view natural phenomena as resulting from nonhuman design. There's a lot of research that supports that theory. God makes intuitive sense.
When children are directly asked about the origin of animals and people, they tend to prefer explanations that involve an intentional creator, even if the adults who raised them do not. We are promiscuous teleological thinkers. We see intent where there is none, hence anti-evolution creatuionists. God makes intuitive sense.
There's a classic classic demonstration of what anthropologist Pascal Boyer called a "hypertrophy of social cognition": a willingness to attribute psychological states, including agency and design, even when it is inappropriate to do so. Way back in the 1940's two cognitive psychologists made a simple movie in which geometrical figures circles, squares, triangles moved in certain systematic ways, designed, based on the psychologists’ intuitions, to tell a tale. People seeing the movie instinctively describe the figures as if they were specific people (bullies, victims, heroes) who have goals and desires, and they repeat back pretty much the same story that the psychologists had intended to tell. Other researchers found that you don't even need bounded figures - you can get much the same effect with moving dots, as well as in movies where the ‘characters’ aren't single objects at all, but moving groups, such such as swarms of tiny squares. Nature and inanimate things are seen as people. We attribute human character to damn near everything - we see faces in airplanes, automobiles, bags, bells, buildings, clouds. We hear voices in the wind. The storm rages, the water is silent, the volcano is angry. We are so hypersensitive to signs of human agency that we see intention where all that really exists is artifice or accident. God - an invisible human with agency - makes intuitive sense.
We have two distinct cognitive systems, one for dealing with material objects, the other, which emerged much later in our evolution, for social entities.These systems have incommensurable outputs. Hence we have the evolutionary accident of mind-body dualism ala Rene Descartes. If bodies and souls are thought to be separate, you can have one without the other. Inanimate objects are bodies without souls, and dualism makes it possible to imagine souls without bodies. God makes intuitive sense.
All those classic arguments like Aquinas five ways, don't come from just the thinking mind. They come from the thinking mind (trying to) proving that its intuition was correct. God is not a rational, logical conclusion but rather an intuition, one of those things that you _just know is true_. People don't _see_ God, they _feel_ God, they _sense_ God's presence. The evidence that we see as crap no good very bad not even evidence, boy howdy it hits the old confirmation bias spot. It confirms to them that their intuition is right. That's why, where we keep saying "total lack of evidence," they keep saying "but there's this evidence and that evidence." How do we stop the madness? (We must be mad because we keep doing the same thing and expecting different results.)