RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateReligion • … • u/HermesTheMessenger

Religious ideologies may have served a positive purpose at one time, but currently are a drag on progress. 13 general examples.

*[repost from a reply in another thread]*

Below is a list of ~~12~~ ~~13~~ **14** issues with religions that are a drag on progress in society. The focus is mainly on Christianity, though I think this applies broadly, and I am willing to talk about other non-Christian religions if anyone wants to go that way.

Before the list: I'm not calling religion or the average religious believers as a scourge on humanity. Religions have texts that can be neutrally discussed, and religious believers are mostly kind and honest ... because *most people* are kind and honest. Well, most of the time. With that in mind...

* There are many good parts of the Bible and other religious texts. This is one of the reasons that Ecclesiastes and a few choice quotes from other books are quoted in Christian wedding services and occasionally in some secular ceremonies.

* There are some horrible parts in the Bible, and many that don't translate well into modern times. What many Christians promote *today* as good or evil aren't supported by the Bible. Two examples of many;

**#** [Against "pagan" (aka: not my religion) rituals, while the priestly texts condone rituals that don't differ much from rituals in other religions in modern times.](https://www.biblegateway.com/quicksearch/?quicksearch=blood+thumb&version=NIV)

**#** [For Christmas trees, while the Bible is not.](https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Jeremiah+10%3A1-5&version=NIV)

* There are a few different ways to read religious texts. Two that come to mind are a *literal reading* and *reading as part of an open-ended conversation*. The first is common among Christians and Muslims, but not the majority of either. The second is the tendency for religious Jews. See above about most people being kind and honest.

* *While everything on the list below has been promoted by religious ideals, they have also been fought against for other religious ideals.*

* ***In general, the good does not out weigh the bad, and even if it did, good deeds can't be used to "pay" for bad deeds.***

===========

# **An incomplete list...**

------------- -------------

Zero: Using religion as justification for certain actions without pointing to any specific teachings or scriptures. Using some passages as literal events, and others as figurative.

* Using religion as a justification shuts down open conversations into those actions, and deflects any accountability. Accountability will be a running theme.

1. Citing God/Allah's will as an excuse to not do the right thing. Ex: Vaccine deniers, or most of what follows.

2. Lack of transparency and accountability, leading to the perpetuation and covering up of various crimes. Theft, child rape, ... .

3. Slavery as a managed and acceptable practice.

4. Bigotry against out-groups, varying by religious group and time, including but not limited to;

5. Racism. Some justify it by citing [the Sons of Ham](https://www.biblegateway.com/quicksearch/?quicksearch=sons+of+ham&version=NIV), or in The Book of Mormon (original); 'white and delightsome'.

6. Religious bias against people or groups that aren't in that religion.

7. Artificial hierarchies, based on misogyny.

8. Anti-LGBT.

9. General evidence denial *if that evidence is in conflict with what's in the Bible. The Bible takes precedent ...*

10. *... except when it doesn't.* Then, *the contents of the Bible is ignored if it contradicts what someone wants.* Note point zero.

11. Accelerated end-times theology used to back various abuses. (Yes, the Bible has many passages about Earth being God's and that people are caretakers, not owners.)

12. Medical restrictions that prevent death or harm.

13. The majority of the kind and honest religious people give cover to the ones spreading various forms of hate or misinformation by pointing out that "I'm not them.". Yes, and not all politicians, or cops, are bastards. Pointing to the good ones while not dealing with the bad ones is the issue. The bad actors aren't going to listen to me ... but if they're in the same sect or even religion as you are, they might just listen to you.

=======

=======

Edit 1: Thank you, everyone, for your thoughtful responses. I will review your comments and hopefully provide a satisfactory response.

— 0