RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateReligion • … • u/HermesTheMessenger

People that do not review a religious moral code are being immoral or at best amoral

I posted a version of this on DebateAChristian, and did not get many direct critiques or constructive discussions of what I actually wrote. Since then, I've made a few small but important updates.

## Summary;

There are tools from our shared deep history that can be used to review most (if not all) moral codes as well as other claims and conclusions about what is true or false, wrong or correct. We only have to use them;

* **The principle of identity:** A logical axiom that says a thing is itself and not another thing.

* **Evidence:** Not using evidence forces us to use abstractions or unsubstantiated claims of other people.

* **Reason/logic:** Provides a structure to hang the evidence on and review what that evidence may mean.

* **Emotions:** Emotions are a subset of available evidence, and we should be aware of those of others as well as our own potential emotion-driven motivations and biases.

These tools, along with others, can be used to show if a conclusion is justified, and it can be used to generate new justified conclusions.

People who do not use these tools, plus potentially other tools, to verify their own moral code are being amoral or immoral. Following a claimed -- yet unexamined -- moral code does not mean someone is actually being moral.

#-------------------------------------------------------------------------

**The above is only a brief summary. If you have a valid criticism, please do a quick search of the rest to see if I have addressed it below.**

#-------------------------------------------------------------------------

***[Assumptions and side comments...]***

While I am not personally convinced that any gods worthy of the title exist, for the sake of this post I will tentatively agree that;

* Any claimed god(s) exist, and may best be followed by one or more of the various sects of a specific religion.

* God(s) given morals are innate in everyone's hearts.

* God(s) have a perfect moral code.

* We mere humans do not have unambiguous access to any god's perfect moral code beyond the innate god(s) given morals in our hearts. (After all, we aren't gods, and people disagree on conclusions that they think align with what they think god(s) would agree with.)

Additionally;

* Everyone should take time to review their own moral code. This includes people with or without any theistic or religious views.

* [Knowledge is 'justified true belief'.](https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/knowledge-analysis/)

* It is corrupt to ignore the [best available evidence](https://iep.utm.edu/evidence/) to arrive at a conclusion, even if that conclusion would be justified when the relevant and best evidence was included.

* God(s) may have a 100% objective moral code.

* We mere mortals can work towards something that is more objectively moral, though it will never be 100% objective.

* Arguments over subjective or objective moral codes are a waste of time, and I will not be replying to them.

* I do not speak for anyone else, and I agree that no one religious theist speaks for any other.

With that out of the way, here are the details. When you're ready, we can talk.

#-------------------------------------------------------------------------

***[The 'argument' in more detail]***

There are tools from our shared deep history that can be used to verify any claim about reality, and also to generate new justified conclusions.

One set of claims are the different moral codes people adhere to. ***People who don't bother, or even refuse, to examine their own moral code are being immoral.*** [This has been true even before the first accountants and merchants pressed numbers into clay.](https://sites.utexas.edu/dsb/tokens/from-accounting-to-writing/)

Many moral codes tend to be too abstract and detached from emotions, or rely too much on emotional appeals while ignoring other evidence and/or reason/logic. Some moral codes are also statements and are not open to scrutiny, or are held to be true as a part of an ideology.

Here are the minimum number of tools that are required to reach a justified conclusion on any topic, including any moral code.

* [***The law of identity:*** A thing is itself and not another thing.](https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/identity/)

Examples: A=A, A≠B, [this apple](https://www.applesfromny.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Honeycrisp_NYAS-Apples3.png) is not [this other apple](https://images.albertsons-media.com/is/image/ABS/184020020?$ng-ecom-pdp-desktop$&defaultImage=Not_Available), the idea of a thing is not the thing itself.

The principle of identity keeps us focused on the evidence and the abstract reasoning that we apply to the evidence. It helps us weed out detached abstractions.

It does this by noting the difference between one thing (the abstract word "apple") and another [(this picture of a real apple)](https://www.applesfromny.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Honeycrisp_NYAS-Apples3.png), and possibly drawing an invalid conclusion. The tacit use of the law of identity helps keep us honest with ourselves and with others because using it guides us to identify what we are thinking or talking about.

Yet, the identity principle and other philosophical axioms aren't sufficient to build or even verify a moral code.

As I see it, we mere mortals tend to use three different things in each of our *justified* conclusions: evidence, reason/logic, and emotions. We use these things because they have worked so very well over the eons.

* ***Evidence:*** Not using evidence forces us to use abstractions or unsubstantiated claims of other people.

* ***Reason/logic:*** Provides a structure to hang the evidence on and review what that evidence may mean. Evidence + reason/logic provides knowledge (justified true belief).

* ***Emotions:*** Emotions are a subset of the available evidence. Incorporating emotions -- yours and others -- into a decision can enhance the results and/or prevent mistakes when we reach a conclusion. Attempting to ignore emotions only allows them to guide us to potentially invalid conclusions. Because of that, we should acknowledge our own emotions and other largely hidden biases when making any conclusion on morality. Besides, we are emotional creatures, so ignoring emotions or attempting to suppress them is not actually possible.

While these basic tools come from our shared deep past and are helpful, most people don't keep them in mind while they are determining if something is moral, amoral, or immoral, let alone true or false or something in between.

Back to the primary claim;

* Religious people that do not review their own moral code are being immoral.

I am only talking about those religious people that ***do not*** go through the process of justifying each part of their moral code using an ideologically neutral method that can be used by anyone to justify any conclusion, including those conclusions found in moral codes.

Since that ideologically neutral tools are ones we already use, it is not a valid claim that some other moral code does not need to be reviewed by those ideologically neutral tools.

— 0