RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateReligion • … • u/Veda_OuO

The Soul-Making Defense: An Approach To Rebutting the Argument From Evil

Thesis: The soul-making defense does not adequately account for the evils found on earth, given the proposed existence of a perfect god.

In my discussions with theists, I find that, more than any other argument, the Problem of Evil has a way of sneaking its way to center stage. Offered by the Atheist, the argument aims to highlight the seeming contradiction between the existence of an all-good, all-knowing, all-powerful god and the prolific evils found on Earth.

Just as a refresher, a **traditional Problem of Evil argument** runs something like:

1. If God exists, then God is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect. 2. If God is omnipotent, then God has the power to eliminate all evil. 3. If God is omniscient, then God knows when evil exists. 4. If God is morally perfect, then God has the desire to eliminate all evil. 5. Evil exists. 6. If evil exists and God exists, then either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil. 7. Therefore, God doesn’t exist.

I'm sure both theists and atheists alike have a number of ready objections when encountering the argument phrased in this way, but, for the sake of clarity and orthodoxy, I think this version offers a fair summation of the argument's intended thrust. For the purposes of this thread, I would like to hone in on one of the many objections which one could raise: the "soul-making" defense.

Put very succinctly, **the soul-making defense** argues something like:

God created us as imperfect beings. We are not fit for Heaven upon first creation; so, it is our task on Earth to purge our soul of its inherent evil desires.

Therefore, evil is a necessary learning tool for our imperfect souls. God has designed the world in a way where we can overcome trials and learn through good works thereby purifying our souls in preparation for eternal life. The theist may then look at the world, a place full of great evil, and note that it is well-suited for God's soul-making purpose.

I'd like to know what the community thinks of this type of objection.

* Theists, is this a defense which appeals to you? Do you find it sufficient to stop the PoE argument in its tracks? Are there better and worse versions of the defense; if so, which is your preferred version? * Atheists, what do you make of this type of approach to explain the evils of Earth? What rebuttals do you find to be the most pursuasive when confronted with this objection to the PoE?

The post already quite lengthy, but I'll briefly detail my **favored response** to soul-making defense:

Evil which can plausibly be linked to the improvement of souls encompasses a small fraction of the evils experienced on earth. So, even if we grant the theist that a soul-making process is occuring, *most* of the evils which occur on earth - particularly natural evils - are not included in the scheme. I think this is best demonstrated by a hypothetical:

Imagine a sickly blue whale in the middle of the ocean. It no longer has the strength to swim and slowly sinks to the bottom of the ocean. In the pitch black depths, it struggles for air; terrified and in great pain, some hours later it drowns on the ocean floor, completely alone.

We could all think of examples like this. This case seems problematic for theist offering this response because presumably they need to show how this whale's suffering has contributed to the cleansing of a human soul. It just seems entirely implausible that a whale who suffers a thousand feet below the ocean, in pitch black waters, miles and miles from the nearest human, could sufficiently contribute to any sort of soul-making process.

— 0