Religion is a product of cultural evolution, unaffected by their truth value.
Metaphysical beliefs have existed in great numbers, thousands of them came and went, from before the first human settlements to modern times. Most of them had their share of devotees and shamans, completely enthralled in their exclusive supernaturality and access to their perceived "truth".
The vast majority of beliefs have died out completely, however. Modern society is particularly gripped by Abrahamic faiths, plus some oriental faiths such as buddhism and hinduism. The question I'm attempting to answer is, *what defines the popularity and lifespan of a religion?*
My claim is that a religion's popularity is completely defined by its mechanisms of conversion and fidelity, evolved and sharpened over time. I can break it down in a few "axioms":
- The popularity of a religion is unaffected by its truth value. (Supported by mutually-exclusive religions that have existed and do exist, merit given to one is merit given to all)
- Religions with a harder grip on people will spread, religions with a weaker grip will corrode. (Supported by basic intuition, religions that play into the human psyche intelligently will retain and create believers much better than those who don't)
- Religions undergo cultural development and evolution. Subsects naturally arise, and more sophisticated ones will outgrow weaker ones. This process molds religions into more powerful and gripping variants.
- The human brain is unreliable at truth seeking, it is littered with evolved mechanisms that gave rise to confirmation bias, terror management theory, illusory pattern seeking, social reinforcement, cognitive dissonance, anthropocentrism, etc.
All these wrapped up create the following chain of thought:
*If humans are unreliable at seeking truths, and religions are not defined by truth value, and religions undergo cultural evolution, then modern religions owe their fame to their ability to evolve culturally and play into the human psyche.*
This would explain the suspiciously and conveniently "human" aspects of modern religions: "If you don't believe you spend eternity in hell, if you believe you spend eternity in heaven and see all your loved ones" plays directly into the human reward and punishment system. "The devil will try to convince you otherwise, will try to trick you" shuts down critical thinking and how much merit is given to opposing thoughts. "The creator of this universe made you and loves you" makes you feel special and sacred, which feels good.
To summarize, a religion's popularity is entirely dictated by its cultural evolution. This same thing applies to things such as scams, and moral values. Cultural evolution defines their effectiveness and popularity.