RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateReligion • … • u/guilcol

Even if the resurrection of Jesus Christ is granted as a historical fact, the bridge from that event to the authority of the New Testament and the Bible as a whole is loose, relying on circular reasoning and assumptions that cannot be historically verified.

For the sake of this argument, I will grant the resurrection as true and focus only on the connection between that event and the Bible’s authority.

The resurrection is the central claim of Christianity and, if true, it can validate Jesus as a divine entity. Moving from this event to the conclusion that the Bible is the infallible word of God is far less secure. The gap between Jesus' resurrection and the authority of Christian scripture is bridged not by unbroken historical evidence, but by appeals to witnesses, church consensus, and internal claims of inspiration that ultimately fold back on themselves. This makes the Bible’s divine status a complete matter of faith that incorrectly (or opportunistically) uses Jesus as an anchor.

The New Testament was written after Jesus’ death by some of his followers. This timing introduces the possibility of opportunism, where his followers could attribute sayings to Jesus that establish their own authority, such as promises of divine revelation or spirit-given guidance. Because the only record of these promises is contained in the very texts claiming inspiration, the logic becomes completely circular, the Bible is authoritative because the Bible says it is. Jesus' resurrection does absolutely nothing to corroborate the Bible.

The role of the early church in recognizing the legitimacy of the scripture is also problematic as proof. Appealing to the church risks another form of circular reasoning, the Bible is validated by the church, and the church is validated by the Bible. This feedback loop offers no independent bridge from Jesus himself to the written texts, only a community reinforcing the authority of the documents it already depends on.

Even the other pillars often invoked such as miracles, fulfilled prophecy, apostolic martyrdom, suffer from reliance on the same sources. Reports of miracles come almost exclusively from Christian writings, leaving little neutral evidence, if any at all. Prophecies are interpreted within the Christian framework itself. Each of these factors cannot, on their own, establish an airtight connection between the resurrection event and the Bible’s claim to be the word of God.

In conclusion, even if the resurrection really happened, the leap to the Bible being the word of God is weak. The link leans on the Bible’s own claims and a church built around those same claims, which ends up being circular. Just because I witnessed a divine event, it does not mean that I can write a book that states that because of that event, I can speak with divine authority.

— 0