RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DebateReligion • … • u/MJtheProphet

To Christians: Could stronger support for some other religion convince you to change your mind?

The question applies more generally than just to Christians, but I thought I'd set a more direct focus, since the argument for the truth of the Christian religion based on the historical record of its origins is popular, well-known (and familiar to me), and rather fully developed. I'm more than willing to see what people of other religions who also argue that the historical record, particularly from their holy texts, demonstrates the truth of their belief have to say.

I ran across [this thought experiment](http://www.patheos.com/blogs/crossexamined/2013/11/a-convincing-holy-book-not-possible/), and thought it would be an interesting one to pose here. Many of the Christians here are educated in the history of their religion, and have clearly faced numerous arguments from atheists that have not proven convincing. You're probably familiar with the points that critics of your religion make regarding the weakness of the historical evidence around Christianity, so you're aware of ways in which it could be stronger; you still think it's strong enough to validate your belief, so the criticisms aren't problematic, but you do understand where the critics are coming from. In this sub, I'm fairly confident this describes a number of people.

Say you come across a holy book from some other religion, relating its own miracle stories. It’s an English translation from an original written in a long-dead language from a foreign culture. And the case for its truth is *very* strong. Where the Bible runs into criticisms, this book does not.

* Rather than a delay in which oral tradition preserved the information, this book was written roughly contemporaneously with the events it describes. * The original was directly translated into English, as compared to the New Testament stories originating in an Aramaic-speaking culture, being written in Greek, and *then* being translated to English. * Our oldest copies of the text *are the originals*, from which the English translation was made. * The book contains stories which directly make claims to being eye-witness testimony of the events (i.e. "I, Thomas, write this account of these miraculous events which occurred before my eyes"), something the gospels don't claim. * There are multiple accounts of the events collected in this book, but unlike the New Testament, these accounts need not be harmonized; there are no contradictions between the stories being told, they're entirely corroborative.

And so on. Whatever reason you find the evidence for the Jesus story convincing, this other holy book matches or exceeds that reason. Would this be enough to convince you to change your religion? Would you, after a few days of fact-checking to make sure to the best of your ability that everything is indeed what it seems to be, convert to this other religion?

I know this seems like a rather boring hypothetical, of the "What if you were convinced that you were wrong?" type. But the point here is rather more interesting, because it highlights how important that historical evidence really is to you. If you wouldn't convert, then it isn't really the historical evidence that convinced you to believe. And if it didn't convince you, why would you think it would convince me?

— 0