RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DemonSchoolIrumakun • … • u/Ruri_997

[Chapter 451 spoilers] In Sullivan's defense

With the story inching closer to tackling the issue of Sullivan somehow acquiring Iruma, I decided to give the story a reread from the very beginning and this greeted me right at the start:

Iruma's parents sold him, which is the first contract and the one that the narrator (apparently Iruma himself) confirms as possible. In the example shown, it's a person selling their own soul though.

Countless people have already brought up the question of if a contract with a demon is void if the thing sold does not belong to the seller in the first place, so I want to move on to the second contract.

Iruma signed and stamped his own adoption paper. If the sales contract was sufficient, why would Sullivan go out of his way and set up another equally secret one which isn't the same (and just coerce Iruma into selling his soul on his own to get a valid contract instead)?

Of course it would be to have an official paper track. While Sullivan dodges the question about Iruma's heritage, he does not say that he adopted him, but instead tells people he has his ways.

Still, he went that extra mile and got an adoption certificate which seems to hold some kind of legal importance.

Border Patrol has been entirely unable to put him under any kind of pressure, lest demand any paperwork from him.

So what made Sullivan expect that anyone would ever ask for receipts? It's impossible to currently tell, and there is still the issue of someone like Baal (or anyone else for that matter) ultimately claiming he forced Iruma to give approval for the contract.

Another issue is if the contract of adoption isn't void too.

In a [Twitter post, Nishi gave a diffuse answer about "Suzuki" even being Iruma's actual surname. ](https://www.reddit.com/r/DemonSchoolIrumakun/comments/10jyhxh/irumas_surname_is_pseudonym_as_per_auhtor_nishi/)This is important because it could mean that there is actually no contractual relationship between Sullivan and Iruma at all (because Iruma is not the contractual party "Iruma Suzuki").

If we assume that the high deities go the route by the book after Shura gets overruled too sometime in the future for being biased (based on the assumption that they act superior and holier-than-thou towards other races) that means Sullivan is mostly off the hook.

The acts Shura describes as illegal are crossing into the human world and keeping a human. Sullivan denied that he "keeps" Iruma. It's only Baal that clarifies that (according to him) "raising" a human is a crime, so we ought to take that statement with a grain of salt.

Furthermore Baal burns the decree with Delkira's seal that bars investigations into the matter \*and\* proclaims Iruma as Sullivan's grandson, so that's just gone too.

So in that constellation he is just someone who took care of some random human with neither of them having any obligation to the other. Meaning Iruma was free to leave at any time, which is where Henri comes in that can (truthfully) confirm that Border Patrol even offered him to erase his memories and go back if he was human.

Sullivan also did not admit to crossing into the human world. There is no hard evidence on the table for it either (and the implication alone might not be enough in a court of law).

So both possible points of prosecution could be fought off successfully.

— 0