How much did Klaasje actually lie?
Good day detectives. Recently I started replaying this game over and over again...again. This time I tried to approach it from a different perspective as a murder mystery proper, and found myself wondering just how much did Klaasje try to manipulate Harry.
Now, there were obvious deceits: her name, history, reason to be in Revachol, etc. She was clearly not an innocent dancer but a girl with a past. Maybe she had been a fomer agent of Corporate Espionage as we could get her to reveal. Maybe even this was just another layer of lies, a backup second layer of covers for Harry and the Hardie boys to feel like they had been 'let in' to the truth while concealing the real truth. I do not think we shall know for sure and things can be confusing, but I think at least to a degree, these lies made sense. A girl with secrets would not want a half-mad drunken copper to chase her past down and put everything into the weekly report. It made sense to lie.
However, were her reasons for calling the RCM a lie?
To our best knoweldge, after the Colonel was hanged, that was very much it. The RCM did not run Martinaise and let's face it, was not particularly functional anyhow, all the while the de facto local lawmen, the Union Militants Hardie boys, were actively covering up for her. For all intents and purposes, the case was over and looked to everyone like a conflict over the strike. Even Harry and Kim, without passing a check to find the bullet/get a super-natural hunch, would almost always conclude this way at first regardless what kind of copper Harry became. There wasn't even a need for the whole 'raped or not' story, which was only there to protect the Hardie boys by justifying the killing should RCM show up.
Yet, she called. Harry and Jean brought a team there, and everything became complicated.
This could not be a calculated decision unless there was a far more complicated web of schemes that demanded it, right? Obviously she was not expecting Harry and not expecting anyone to actually found out about the bullet, but it seems that she called the RCM to remove the body genuinely because she could not bear the sight of the Colonel's body insulted and rotting away. And the same logic applies to the question of 'why reject the rape claim.' Once you are through with the Hardies and they claimed that the Colonel raped her, the easiest, simplest way to end the entire trouble from her perspective would be not contradicting their words. By rejecting the Hardie boys' allegation of rape, she was actively seeding doubts and prolonging the investigation. Why would she do that, if not to stand up for the Colonel's character?
So, were the feelings true?
Of course I am not implying a 'true feeling' as in an awkward college pair dreaming of church and children. They were royally drugged and too cynical for that anyhow. But were they together truly because they found solace in each other's company? Because however fucked up shitty people they were, they found some disco together at that moment?
I am questioning this because I don't think Klaasje lied *that much*. She really was a girl trying to get herself off the hook and not some actively malicious force at work playing Titus/Ruby, Colonel, and RCM like pawns.
Prior to your threatening to throw her behind the bars into the hands of the Moralintern, I think the extent of her lies was very limited to protecting her identity. The entire 'facade' was not a performance, in fact, it was the contrarary. She was ithe more honest one at that point comparing to Titus and Elizzabeth because she was not actively lying with the whole rape story!
I tried to approach the interview with her with all kinds of different Harrys: the logical and calculating one, the 'people' one good with words and human nature, the batshit insane one high on electrochemistry, and even the brute. Yet every time I came to the same conclusion: She really was not a master manipulator, at least not anymore. She was not playing a game there. The 'witch hunting' of your skills near the end, the pressure to arrest her, were just that, witch hunting. While the doubt was started by Volition, aka. the 'sane cop', the anti-temptation, the ones pushing it hardest near the end was Drama, the one creating something exciting out of nothing.
And this was just so profoundly sad. Ruby, if you handled the encounter with her wrong, could die thinking Klaasje betrayed her, or even manipulated her to begin with. But she did not. She only throw Ruby under the bus when you threaten to put her behind bars and by that point the panic seemed real. I don't think there was a grand design at play but more like just the usual case: miserable people failing harder together.
Am I compromised?