[OC] Attempt to fix the martial/caster divide with expanding the maneuvers system for 5/5.5e.
There is a common trend of people complaining about a martial vs caster divide in 5/5.5e. Which I do agree with to an extent exists, but not as much as some people that post on here. However my biggest issues has been that when people make these posts they hardly ever try to offer up a solution to this problem.
Edit: To clarify, I know that most people complain that the divide is martial classes run out of gas faster than casters. At my table I don't have that problem, I do run 4-6 encounters of various strength during a normal adventuring day with 1-2 short rests. I even run dungeon turns and use other skills and procedures from previous editions I learned and other systems that help those adventuring days go smoothly. The divide I do think exists is the power creep from cantrips, full caster multiclassing, and less options for pure martial characters that do fun effects without removing their attacks (like many cantrips do). Hence the expansion to the maneuver system and granting it to the 3 main martial classes. This gives them the ability to engage with a system how they want their character to be and provide some extra utility in some capacity.
There have been some solutions with reworking classes, adding new features, and expanding the game. Many go to one extreme of rewriting entire classes completely, which I'm not a huge fan of that idea, but do enjoy seeing that homebrew to see where the system could go and learning from them.
So here is a possible solution that could be dropped into a 5/5.5e game that has worked for my tables in some capacity over the last few years. This originally started out as an entirely different system that was added but then as I fiddled and tweaked with it I realized I liked the Battle master maneuvers too much and wanted to just expand the system. In this version maneuvers are granted at level 2 to Barbarian, Fighter, and Monk and slowly expand from there. Which were present in the original 5e playtest in a capacity for all fighters.
[Combat Maneuvers](https://homebrewery.naturalcrit.com/share/nQMmR2_AKC6v) system with 22 new maneuvers.
[New Maneuvers as an item-forge.org JSON file for printing as cards](https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/82te9bx6uuyrji131mfeu/new_maneuver_card_items.json?rlkey=zdk15697n3v7wt469dz77gjpx&st=j96rpybh&dl=0) [item-forge.org link](https://item-forge.org)
## Some design notes
I wanted to expand the Battle master Maneuvers and grant them at level 2 for the 3 martial classes. This seemed like a fairly nice addition point. As well I wanted to ensure that the current Battlemaster still felt unique and empowered with this addition. So there are a few things I tried to do while building this system:
1. The Battlemaster gets more maneuvers, dice, and larger dice constantly. The other classes or Fighter subclasses don't get as many and can't change them as often. 2. I wanted to encourage gaining higher levels in martial classes beyond level 5, so that is where the new level 8 and 15 abilities come from. 3. On page 2 of the document you'll see where I have listed requirements for new and existing maneuvers. The idea here is that with the updated battlemaster where they can ignore ability score requirements and swap one at level up the battle master can gain any maneuver that is not tied directly to a class. - For instance, all the level 3/5/7 requirements allow the battle master to get those a level earlier than any other class. - Some require an ability score and the battle master is the only one who gets to ignore those. 4. Maneuvers tied to a specific class such as buried rage and empty focus require 4 levels of that class to acquire it to help against multiclass dip shennaigans. 5. Some of the new ones allow scaling or expanding more dice as you get higher level like cantrips. This is used to eliminate the need for a save to make them go faster while allowing things to be added later. Examples include: - Spell Breaker doesn't let the spell caster save to prevent disadvantage, so it doesn't add in the extra damage until 5th level. - Slowing strike gets stronger once you get to 7th level and acts more like the slow spell. 6. You need to be cautious of the 5.5e relentless feature for battle master, it grants a 1d8 every round to use for maneuvers. As a result Curative Salve and Herbal Poultice have restrictions on how you can use them to prevent unlimited healing. I think they are good restrictions though. The intent is that you can either help an unconscious friend or quickly patch up yourself. 7. Some maneuvers are spells reworked, like adrenaline surge is haste but much shorter or feat of strength is a spiderclimb-like spell for strong folks. As such these may have a once per short/long rest restriction on them to help balance them out. 8. To prevent multiclass shenanigans some maneuvers that are powerful require 5+ levels of barbarian, fighter, or monk. This means a 5/3 barbarian/fighter can't pick up things like adrenaline surge yet, and that is intended. It's roughly a 3rd level spell effect without concentration and the major drawback so they need to dedicate a bit more to get it.
## Areas I'd like to alter and get better balance feedback
- Herbal poltuce: I honestly think this just needs to get 2 dice of healing at level 5, then maybe level 7 get a 3rd die without having to spend more. It is a full action and has limits on it. - Lingering Wound: The idea for this flavor is that you are hitting an area and causing a lot of blood or bruising a rib that causes some pain at the start of their turn. The intent is to give martials a way to do damage that isn't B/P/S and trigger a concentration check. - Slowing Strike: I'm really not sure how to balance this one to make it feel impactful but not overpowered. - Maneuver Upgrade: I think this is interesting and fun. Letting a maneuver change as they get more powerful seems cool to me.
## Preemptive answers to some questions/feedback
- Q: Why doesn't X maneuver exist? A: This is not comprehensive, I'm just one guy having fun between my sessions. Propose a new maneuver if you think something is missing. Notably I think there are a bunch of skill improvements that should exist like Ambush and Commanding Presence. I just haven't had time. - Q: Why don't you include Paladin/Ranger/Rogue? A: Because I didn't feel like they needed it, this is for the classes I thought could use the boost with a new system and some more options. I think the ranger getting this at 4th level and half the progression would be a solid replacement of hunter's mark. Rogue I think they could get the feat for free at 4th level or expand the 5.5e sneak attack dice trade feature and let them learn two or three on-hit maneuvers and let them trade in sneak attack dice. - X seems magical, I don't like this! Cool, I haven't tied any flavor to them so it's up for your interpretation. If you don't like it then you don't need to use this system. - You don't have images and a better layout, this isn't usable! Again, I'm one guy having fun with a homebrew that some of my players use, maybe if I publish this as a final draft I'll make it look pretty and get art for it. For now, it's just a basic system to help martial characters. - YOU HATE MY SORLADIN/HEXADIN/WHATEVER WITH THIS RULE TO LIMIT ARMOR! It's optional even though I think it is warranted. As a DM I hate when people talk about doing a "2 level dip in fighter for con save, armor, and action surge" or rocking a paladin/sorcerer with medium armor. Don't use it at your table if you don't like it. I grew up on 2e then 3e, so this is very reasonable from my experience. Magic exists to grant these casters AC like mage armor and shield or class features. This seems reasonable to suggest that if you want higher AC to either invest in that spell/class feature or get a feat or two to help reign in power of full casters and mulitclass dips where they may get this new maneuver feature to get things they don't normally get in their class. But again, don't use it at your table if that's what you want to play.
Edit: added clarification above to what I think about the martial/caster divide above.