RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/DnDcirclejerk • … • u/Carrente

D&D is a HEROIC FANTASY GAME which means it is perfect for emulating HEROIC FANTASY STORIES

I mean it can't actually support when played as written stories where the threat of death can't be easily mitigated by magic readily available to players. And it can't really handle the survival/overland travel aspects of fantasy stories. And it definitely can't really handle duels against a single opponent of similar size and skill to the heroes, or in fact particularly interesting fights against a giant monster either. At least it can mostly support the idea of challenging enemies way beyond your skill set with comprehensive advice for using environmental factors and player skill to overcome numerical disparity? No, it can't do that either. Best you can get is "if you find the spells that break the maths wide open basically nothing is a threat or it oneshots you"

Well fantasy heroes also get involved in politics and kingdom building, right, so D&D must be able to emulate those aspects of the story. No, it can't do that very interestingly either.

But it is very good at heroic fantasy adventures, you know, all those beloved fantasy stories about a group of people who fight only appropriate numbers of enemies of a roughly even skill level and spread of abilities about 6-8 times a chapter, and largely choose to ignore things like "having the right tools for the job", "surviving hostile environments" and "travelling" because they're boring.

— 0