The ‘she tied them and left them’ theory
The defence wants to say that Lindsay tied the cords and left the children to die but didn’t actually stay there applying force herself to ensure they died, beyond losing consciousness.
I personally don’t buy this at all for many reasons including that Lindsay is a perfectionist and would not leave the matter of them actually being dead in any way up to chance.
However let’s look at the argument.
One of the benefits to the defence in saying this is to reduce the atrocity of the act by making it more passive and pointing to some level of shame or regret on Lindsay’s part.
But by the biggest reason for the argument is to create a shorter time frame for the murders. This is so that they can posit the voice started only after Patrick’s phone call, thereby eliminating that phone call as evidence of her mental state during the act and mitigating the premeditation implied if she began killing as soon as Patrick left.
The only even slightly possible way for Lindsay to kill three children and attempt suicide three different ways in the shorter time frame is if she automated the process for all three rather than overseeing each one individually to the end point.
Let’s just imagine that is the case.
Why then would she not attempt to revive the children instead of proceeding to her suicide frenzy?
If the killing only commenced from after the phone call then the timeline during which their airways were blocked and up until she began attempting suicide was much much shorter than in the CW’s. Given that the call finished at 5:34 and she was seen outside at 5:50 that means absolute max 10 minutes from tying Dawson, the first of the three victims, to starting the suicide attempts. And that’s already allowing very little time for the suicide part. But let’s just be generous for the sake of argument - and granting that the 5:50 sighting timing could be a little off. About 10 minutes from Dawson being tied. Let’s say 7 minutes from Cora being tied. Let’s say 4 minutes from Callan being tied.
Lindsay herself has said that the voice stopped after she had strangled Callan. If the children were all tied in quick succession and simply left to die rather than watched dying individually that would leave a real chance in Lindsay’s mind they could be saved. At least a possibility for at least one of them. Callan especially. And this chance might be materially enhanced given her skills as a nurse and capacity to intervene in a meaningful way. It might also be enhanced by the fact that she didn’t personally apply constant pressure and had no way of knowing for certain if the bands had really held tight enough. There was a chance she could save one or all of her children at that point.
And yet in that scenario, presented by the prosecution, when the voice stopped Lindsay did not 1. Remove the bands. 2. Attempt CPR. 3. Call 911.
No. When the supposed voice supposedly stopped Lindsay didn’t even bother to check whether the children could be saved. She simply proceeded directly to part 2 of the plan.
Because the voice was never real. And both parts 1 and 2 of the plan were all hers, all along.