The bracket system might be the worst thing to ever happen to commander online discourse.
This has proven once again that Magic players are incapable of seeing nuance once given a list of guidelines and told to use common sense when deck building.
Old RC “Here’s a banlist of the most problematic cards. Please consider whether or not to include similar cards too.”
Players: “so anything not on this list is fair game and anyone who complains about me playing anything is a sore loser? Got it!”
WotC: “Here are 5 brackets of general play experience to expect, and guidelines about how to approach deck building to achieve that experience”
Players: “these are rigid deckbuilding rules and anything I build within them is fair game, and anyone who complains is a sore loser? Got it!”
It’s a real intelligence vs wisdom metaphor.
Intelligence is knowing that the “Abzan Armor” precon is Bracket 3 due to having a game changer, and that you can make a thrasios/tymna stax deck well within the guidelines of bracket 2.
Wisdom is knowing that those decks absolutely do not belong in those brackets.
Edit: Not a lot of people in the comments proving me wrong about “Magic players don’t understand nuance.”