RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/EDH • … • u/NotTwitchy

The bracket system might be the worst thing to ever happen to commander online discourse.

This has proven once again that Magic players are incapable of seeing nuance once given a list of guidelines and told to use common sense when deck building.

Old RC “Here’s a banlist of the most problematic cards. Please consider whether or not to include similar cards too.”

Players: “so anything not on this list is fair game and anyone who complains about me playing anything is a sore loser? Got it!”

WotC: “Here are 5 brackets of general play experience to expect, and guidelines about how to approach deck building to achieve that experience”

Players: “these are rigid deckbuilding rules and anything I build within them is fair game, and anyone who complains is a sore loser? Got it!”

It’s a real intelligence vs wisdom metaphor.

Intelligence is knowing that the “Abzan Armor” precon is Bracket 3 due to having a game changer, and that you can make a thrasios/tymna stax deck well within the guidelines of bracket 2.

Wisdom is knowing that those decks absolutely do not belong in those brackets.

Edit: Not a lot of people in the comments proving me wrong about “Magic players don’t understand nuance.”

— 0