RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/EDH • … • u/Metanoia_143

Bracket Placement Blind Spots: Your Deck is Bracket 2

I know, another post about the bracket system. I'll keep it very focused and towards a good end.

I'm overall a fan of the bracket system and think it has largely been a success. However, I've noticed that a common mistake is people classifying their decks as bracket 3 when it clearly does not play like a 3. I don't know if this is a holdover from when bracket 2 was associated with Precon power levels, or if it's a bit of an ego thing, whether people realize it or not ("*my* deck can't be a 2, that where the weak decks sit"), but a list has to be pretty powerful and focused to play as a 3 even if it may be a 3 on paper.

The games that precipitated this were two Speltable games labelled bracket 3, where a couple of the players had lists that were, in their own admission, "just thrown together". One was a Teysa Karlov list where he played not a single creature with a death effect, and not a single token producer. One was a Maralyn list that didn't ramp or trigger Maralyn once. The players seemed to have decent overall knowledge of cards, and there was no pubstomp scenario (I was playing a \[\[Tameshi, Reality Architect\]\] list with two game changers that wins about 30% of the time by swinging with angel tokens off of \[\[Finale of Glory\]\] around turn 8), but these advertised 3s were more a jumble of cards.

I'm not writing this to dunk on those players, and I also misevaluate my decks to some degree as well. What I'm trying to get across is that bracket 3 is, by the written system, meant to be focused, high-card quality, and consistently working toward a win by a certain, reasonably quick turn. It's harder to build a 3 than one thinks, and we should be careful about bracket "inflation". Bracket 2 and 3 are both fun spots to play, but they are more different than we think and your quick homebrews should be slotted accordingly.

Have you guys seen this phenomenon in your own games? Do you feel there's a sort of automatic push to evaluate decks up a bracket, or do you feel it goes more in the other direction?

— 0