RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/EDH • … • u/KAM_520

I Made a Commander Player Alignment Chart and It Got Completely Out of Hand

Wake up bb new EDH player type system just dropped. Tag yourselves! Note this is half-serious and for entertainment purposes only. Also this is an AI-free zone; I did this on the elliptical at the gym this morning lol, some people just write like this sorry about it

Ten Types of Commander Players:

1. Sodium Free Spike ("SFS") 2. Alien Brewmaster 3. Stockholm Syndrome Spike ("SSS") 4. Melvorthos Hipster 5. Dino Brat 6. Typal Goober 7. EDH All-Star 8. Yu-Gi-Oh Dropout

These are in no particular order.

**1. Sodium Free Spike**: This is the player whose mental orientation to the game revolves around winning entirely, but whose table presence is rather benign. They are often friendly and low-key. Will \[\[Opposition Agent\]\] your land fetch but will explain to you why they are doing it in a nice way, and they will nod with approval if you remove it. Should probably avoid the more casual tables because their matter-of-fact, unapologetic play-to-win energy is completely at odds with the more outspokenly opinionated casual player types. The natural villain of casual EDH, this type of player prioritizes optimization, staples, and WR% over other factors.

Spikiness: Very high

Saltiness: Very low

Creativity: Low (generally favors proven cards/decks and is extremely practical)

Politics: Moderate

Example: Logan Doan from CriticalEDH

Natural Enemy: Politics Pusher (shifts the axis away from optimized individual game actions), Dino Brat (complains about the SFS instead of upping their game), Melvorthos Hipster (SFS would run 98 staples and 2 basics if it increased their WR by 0.7%)

**2. Alien Brewmaster**: This strange bird is somehow both a Spike player and a hipster. This is the person getting yelled at on [r/competitiveedh](r/competitiveedh) sub for having unconventional ideas. Orientation revolves around winning, but they are big believers in brewer’s advantage and want to explore new ideas. They tend to believe that other players haven’t “solved” existing deck archetypes so they will spend a lot of time on Scryfall looking for the next big innovation. They have no problem cutting staples if they believe it will improve the deck’s win percentage. Note that this player is discovery-oriented, not self-expression oriented; their goal isn't to be different for its own sake but rather to improve their decks’ power by finding cards and strategies others haven't thought of.

Spikiness: Very High

Saltiness: Low

Creativity: High

Politics: Varies

Example: Sam Black

Natural Enemy: Sodium-Free Spike (the gatekeepers of their deck concepts and the champions of what is already proven to work)

**3. Politics Pusher, aka the Yapper, aka 4-D Chess Player**: This is the big talker. Generally this is a Spike player who relies on table politics to overcome any shortcomings in their deck lists or cards in hand. They will sandbag and try to get other players to use interaction before they ever use theirs. They want to make deals whenever they can. Generally extroverted with strong personalities. Note that this player isn’t defined by opinions about deck power level or individual card choices; their chatter is focused on in-game actions. Compare the Politics Pusher’s “That Esper Sentinel is a problem, does anyone have removal?” to the Melvorthos Hipster’s groans about a boring staple or the Dino Brat’s allegations that Esper Sentinel should be a game changer (unless they have one). This is the most “e-sports” player type.

Spikiness: Very High

Saltiness: Moderate

Creativity: Varies

Politics: Very High

Example: Blackneto from Tabletop Jocks, Evan Pierce aka FreedomWaffle

Natural Enemy: Yu-Gi-Oh Dropout (4-D chess player can’t work with the player who entirely ignores the social layer of the game), Dino Brat (too stubborn, doesn’t “get it”), Taboo Troll (doesn't want to play ball, enjoys flouting the social atmosphere), Alien Brewmaster (doesn't know how to politic as well because they don't understand what the Brewmaster is doing)

**4. Stockholm Syndrome Spike**: This is the casualpilled Spike player whose ambitions are somewhat disguised. Their mental orientation to the game revolves around winning but they have succumbed to “spirit of casual” ideas in spite of their natural inclinations. They will make token concessions like cutting Sol Ring to score political points or if they feel like their pod is demanding this, but they will often still have decks that are slightly more powerful than what their pod is playing. This is the “my deck is a 6.99/10” min maxer. This player might make low-key comments about other decks’ card choices or power level but they will virtually never get upset about these things (their inner Spike “gets it”). This player is generally very low salt unless it’s a Rule 0 issue, in which case they are probably the saltiest player of any type; this player relies heavily on "rules" to manage the power level of their own decks and avoid red flags, so they'll get very angry at anyone who decides to ignore these things.

Spikiness: High but somewhat suppressed; more expressed in gameplay than deck building

Saltiness: Low unless Rule 0 is violated, in which case extremely high

Creativity: Low to moderate

Politics: At least moderate

Example: Josh Lee Kwai from Game Knights

Natural Enemy: Taboo Troll (Rule 0 nemesis, tends to dismiss the TT’s generally true claims “My deck isn't that strong” as bad faith excuses), Melvorthos Hipster (doesn’t respect what the SSS is doing), EDH All-Star (clash over the purpose of the social contract, SSS leans on social contract as rules defining “fair game” while All-Star is more focused on vibes and the fun of the table; SSS is much more comfortable playing disagreeable strategies), Themselves (if only they could play what they wanted to)

**5. Melvorthos Hipster**: This is a Johnny deck artist whose brewing style is all about thematic consistency or mechanical coherence or both. This may be the most opinionated player type when it comes to critiquing other players’ decks and gameplay. Not only do decks need to be fundamentally casual, they ought to be original, down to the last card choice. This is the player type most likely to criticize what you’re doing for reasons that have nothing to do with gameplay. [r/edhbrews](r/edhbrews) is filled with this mindset. "Unique", "weird", and "unpopular" cards/decks are their catnip. This player secretly loves EDHREC.

Spikiness: Low

Saltiness: High to Very High

Creativity: Very High

Politics: Varies

Example: Tomer Abramovici from Commander Clash

Natural Enemy: Everyone except other players of the same type (snobby)

**6. Dino Brat**: This is one of the more common player types to encounter in a casual pod. This is the core “Do the Thing” Timmy player who is trying to have fun, not win as their primary objective—but their fun is highly correlated with the success of their deck. Not as pedantic about card choices as the Melvorthos Hipster, but if this player isn’t enjoying the game you will definitely hear about it. I affectionately call them Dino Brats not because they have to play dinosaur decks but because dinosaur players are a very easy-to-recognize example of this type of player. This player is essentially “the meta” in B2-3. This player might try to politic a lot but they encounter mixed success because this player (not always) is the most prone to tilt over threat assessment and get mad at other players for doing things that they themselves do, like not paying the 1 and using interaction on key pieces, etc.

Spikiness: Moderate

Saltiness: Very High

Creativity: Low to Moderate

Politics: Varies

Example: Jimmy Wong from Game Knights

Natural Enemy: Taboo Troll (these players' primary goal is to stop Dino Brats from doing the thing), Sodium-Free Spike (cannot grok the Dino Brat’s entitled attitude)

**7. Typal Goober**: More innocent and less opinionated than the Dino Brat or Melvorthos Hipster, this player enjoys playing silly piles of typal cards, or similarly thematic decks. Bonus points for offbeat typal decks and oddball cards within more popular archetypes. Cards make it into their decks based on UwU and OH COOL at least as often as practical reasons. This player typically relies on the Dino Brats or Melvorthos Hipsters to police the pod’s power level. Newer players start here not infrequently. Will often only be openly salty if you interact with their commander: this is the type of player who likes boardwipes because they affect everyone but feels like pinpoint interaction is mean. Note that this player does not necessarily always play typal decks but that vibe is noticeable in what they do play.

Spikiness: Very low

Saltiness: Low

Creativity: At least moderate

— 0