Miquella's Nightmare
So I have to ask, how many people are taking the "realm of shadow" seriously as being anything other thany a *nightmare* that Miquella is having after enduring years of horrifying abuse at the hands of Mohg and his followers?
Of course the *worst* part of this nightmare is Mohg's followers' insistence that this is all *Miquella*'s fault, that because he was so charming Mohg bears no moral responsibility for anything he did because obviously "Miquella must have really wanted it." But there is no particular reason that we can or should take anything else in the realm of shadow particularly seriously other than as a symptom of the depth of Miquella's delirium as a result of being injected with vast quantities of cursed blood in an ultimately fruitless attempt to force him to accept Mohg's amorous advances.
There are *some* truths scattered among all of the insanity. For instance, Miquella really did prefer Radahn to Mohg...who *wouldn't*? And the pleas of St. Trina to put an end to all this insanity really do come from Miquella's heart. Marika really did have a child with a name starting with "Me" whom she then erased from history for extremely sinister reasons. One has to credit Miquella for having put as much of that together as he managed, considering the circumstances.
But that doesn't mean you have to swallow everything else at face value, most especially the idea that not only being kidnapped by Mohg, but the War of the Shattering, the destruction of the Elden Ring, not to mention the Night of the Black Knives that provoked it, were all "just as planned" and Miquella was steepling his fingers and chucking darkly the whole time in his cocoon. That is the one point I have to dispute most, but I'm still puzzled that anyone could be assuming that, just because the player can interact with the realm of shadow in the game, that means it's something other than a dream or illusion.
Elden Ring (and the body of work preceding it) have plenty of references to things that are not what they seem. The second phase of the Rennala fight and the Lichdragon Fortissax battle are the most explicit, but the second phase of the Radagon fight should only be slightly behind (though plenty of people don't seem to pick up on all the nearly heavyhanded similarities to the Rennala fight there). The base game also presents a lot of "alternate reality" hijinks other than "this fight (and attendant rewards) brought to you by the power of imagination of a demigod (rather than because there is any evidence it *really* happened)."
I know that before the DLC dropped there was plenty of speculation that it would involve having the player interact with the dreams of important characters somehow. But I'm not seeing a lot of that now, it seems most people are inexplicably convinced that the Land of Shadow is completely real and nothing there can be explained simply as "this is a really bad trippy dream influenced by injecting way too many psychoactives."
Consider the alternatives for a moment. If Miquella planned to be kidnapped by Mohg after putting himself in his cocoon, then he also must have planned the Night of the Black Knives, using Ranni and Rykard as his puppets as well.
If we're going that far, why not accuse him of forcing Marika to marry herself and give birth to a pair of Omens as well as the curses on himself and Malenia?
Hell, let's just go whole hog and make him the culprit behind the erasure of Melina and expulsion of her father, all those personally loyal to him, and anyone else too likely to piece together what she'd done? That may seem chronologically impossible, but if we're going to swallow the camel and accept the Land of Shadow as 'real' then why strain at a gnat?