RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/Eldenring • … • u/GlitteringDingo

The DLC pretty much proves the main ending(s) are bad endings.

Note: I will be referring to the Greater Will and Two Fingers interchangeably throughout this post. I know the DLC shows they may be entirely separate entities, but I can't keep straight which does what, so if I get it wrong, sorry.

Pre-SotE, it seemed to be widely accepted that Marika was either a tyrant or a failed god. She fucked things up, either purposefully or by accident. This made it seem like the main ending, and the offshoot ones with mending runes, would be good, as you could fix what was wrong with the Golden Order and make things prosperous again. Many also considered Ranni's ending to be a good one, in a "No gods no masters" sort of sense. Only the Frenzied Flame ending was argued to be objectively bad, with some still supporting even that one.

I think the DLC shows us that the regular endings fix nothing, and that Ranni was correct, and in a literal way, not just philosophically like we used to think. My reasoning comes from the backstory we get about Marika in the Land of Shadow.

The first important detail is Marika's actions leading up to, and immediately after ascending to godhood. She was a desperate young woman, watching her friends and family systematically murdered. She didn't become a god out of ambition or personal desire, she seemingly did so as what she saw as the only solution to this problem. And, upon doing so, she did not wreak havoc upon the land, or the hornsent. One of her first acts was to create a healing aura on her home, despite them all being dead. This characterizes her as loving, kind, and even sentimental.

The second detail, combined with the existence of Radagon, and the shadowbound beasts, shows that the Greater Will was calling the shots for most of Marika's godhood, not her. That detail is "the betrayal." Calling it that is interesting, because for the hornsent to call it that, they must have considered her an ally or even friend at some point. They also refer to the "seduction," which I think is a clever word for what really happened. After Marika became a god, the Greater Will slowly began overwriting her personality and will with its own. Marika betrayed the hornsent because the Greater Will wishes to bring the world under its order, and in the beginning stages, used Marika's fear and anger towards the people that killed her family to get her to subjugate them. This is also why that section of history is more brutal than later fights, as Marika's emotions were being used to fuel it. From that point on, we don't see much of a loving, kind, or sentimental Marika. In fact, by the time of the game itself, she's about as far from it as possible. All peoples not under the Golden Order are subjugated or killed. Thousands of soldiers are thrown into likely unnecessary battles in order to conquer the entire world. Godfrey shows some affection towards his sons, while Marika locked them away where nobody could see them. Marika/Radagon enter into several marriages seemingly for no other reason than strategically, either to have an Elden Lord, create offspring that could replace her when the GW was done with her, or to gain more territory, in the case of Renalla.

So, what I think happened, in order, was that Marika ascended to godhood to stop the violence in her lands, created some time of peace, and began slowly being brainwashed by the Greater Will. The breaking point was getting her to attempt genocide on the hornsent. After that, she began losing herself to godhood, and Radagon is a physical manifestation of that. I imagine Radagon exists to completely override Marika, should she attempt to reclaim her selfhood, or act of her own accord. This all changed her from a kind and caring person, into a cold, emotionless conqueror with no desire but to bring everything into Order. I think the Shattering was the last thing Marika ever did of her own free will. From then on, she was completely imprisoned in the Erdtree, until we meet her, and Radagon immediately takes over.

In conclusion, I think this proves that the Golden Order not just shouldn't be fixed, but that it CAN'T be fixed. Elden Lords came and went, likely tossed aside when they dissented against Marika/GW. We can use the mending runes to make changes to the Elden Ring, and try to make a change, but eventually, the Greater Will can and will reassert itself, meaning any change is short term and ultimately meaningless. So, Ranni's plan to shirk godhood altogether is the only way out. It might not make a better world, but it is the only way to make one free of the influence of the GW. The Order cannot be fixed, because it isn't broken. It is exactly as the Greater Will wishes it to be, and nobody is strong enough to overcome that from within.

Technically this also means that Miquella's plan was likely doomed to fail as well, for the same reasons. St. Trina even calls godhood "a prison," which I think further adds weight to this idea.

— 0