(The Witcher) The Elder Blood is a closed causal loop that Ciri herself creates and perpetuates across time
So I’ve been cooking this theory for a while and I think it actually holds up pretty well across the books, games, and all the old forum threads. The Elder Blood isn’t a straight bloodline that starts with Lara Dorren. It’s a closed time loop that Ciri herself keeps creating. In at least one timeline she fails to stop the White Frost (or loses control of her powers) and the catastrophe flings a child of that bloodline, Alvin. Back through the spheres.
That’s why Alvin has such similar abilities, why he becomes Jacques de Aldersberg, and why he’s obsessed with the Frost and “saving” humanity the wrong way. He’s the failed version of the chosen one, the dark mirror.
The Law of Surprise keeps yanking Geralt into the loop because the blood itself is entangled across realities; Geralt’s repeated “I claim the Law of Surprise” moments aren’t coincidence, they’re the mechanism. And the only reason our timeline works is because Geralt keeps choosing Ciri as “something more” than destiny. That free will choice is what finally lets her succeed instead of becoming the Destroyer.
It also lines up with all the recent Witcher 4 speculation about her taking a version of the Trial. She’s not just becoming a witcher for the aesthetic — she’s deliberately dulling or corrupting the Elder Blood so the loop can’t restart and produce another Alvin. The seed that “will not sprout but burst into flame” is Ciri… and she’s the one trying to make sure it never has to bloom again.