RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/FermiParadox • … • u/agentoutlier

They might have done the wrong thing in Project Hail Mary (spoiler)

So just for a second imagine we are in the Project Hail Mary universe.

Last warning for those that still want to read the book or movie. I am not going to spoiler tag everything:

>!spoiler TLDR; (zoo + dark forest = farm = we are pests)!<

>!spoiler In Project Hail Mary we find out a single cell like organism just happens to produce enormous amount of energy but requires certain type of CO2 atmosphere planet. We also find out where not alone and just happen to meet another alien at exactly the same time period. !<

What this means is life is very common. Like exceedingly common. Likewise for civilizations yet till now we did not see any. Which means likely Zoo. Except worse.

So what this probably means is a far more advanced civilization essentially has cornered off our part of the galaxy to grow ~~photophage~~ astrophage. Like an organism that just happens to produce that much energy is probably not an accident.

So the humans and other aliens take the sick part of the crop and bring it over.

Do you know what farmers do when there is a sick part of the crop?

So a sequel of Project Hail Mary should be "project don't use the astrophage killer" (I'm trying to remember the name something amoeba) and start getting out of our solar system. And that should absolutely happen once the people on Earth find out about Rocky.

That is they should accept the fate of the earth and start figuring out how to harvest off of Venus.

Otherwise annihilation.

And remember if you think the alpha alien is going to be moral... just recall how common life must be to meet the Eridians (spelling not sure). Like common enough it is no big deal to squash us probably.

EDIT I'm just going to delete the post because I can see people downvoting so perhaps the book just covered everything and I forgot.

For one Tau Ceti not having Astrophage yes might indicate a solution to kill the astrophage but it could also indicate that it was just harvested.

EDIT look I get you guys I missed some details on the book and forgot names but lets back up here for a second and think about what the Fermi Paradox is. Where are the aliens?

* We find aliens (first the astrophage). That means Rare Earth is out the window. * We find a breeding organism that can spread across to other solar systems: Which means Von Neumann probes are easily possible * That breeding organism just happens to be a perfect fuel source and shows something **like it** is possible which means collecting shit loads of energy possible. * We then later find a civilization who I guess you know to make it slightly more believable that we have not had aliens find us early did not know about space travel. * The great filter if there is one has been greatly moved ahead in the future.

Why in Project Hail Mary's universe were they're not aliens that came and visited us before?

And here I guess are the optimistic Andy Weir solutions:

1. This it the first time something like this ever happened and no civilizations could travel across to other solar systems without the astrophage. 1. All civilizations besides the human civilizations appear to not care about space travel or are aware of it.

Yes it could be a giant coincidence but man you can bet all the damn scientist working on this one of them would have to ask what I'm asking here... With the above information all the darker theories of the Fermi Paradox become possible and I bet the plan to go to Tau Ceti in itself would be highly questioned as it could be a massive [Honey Pot](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honeypot_%28computing%29). "Oh look the trajectory of nearby civilizations detected that would be killing our precious energy source."

Even if a super alpha alien does not exist... guess what we now know we have a whole bunch of other solar systems that apparently have knowledge of astrophage and apparently life is crawling all over the place. I'm not a fan of Dark Forest Theory but one could easily see how some other civilization might not go to Tau Ceti but instead exploit the astrophage. They build their entire civilization on it and are only like 10 light years. We on the other hand eradicate it and we just sent a beacon that hey we did that over here. ... Let us hope they are nice like the Rock aliens.

— 0