14 yr old soccer ref me vs Karen Coach
I shared this story with my son today and realized it may fit here.
My first real job was a a referee for soccer (Football to the rest of the world). I worked for the local club and would usually get 2-3 games a weekend at the same field. Because it was a local club, I knew players and parents throughout the different teams and in general things went well.
One coach, who we shall call Karen, knew me from my summer swim club. She was normally very nice and I had been the ref for a couple of their games the previous season. They moved up an age group this season and it was their first with goalies. Most of the teams had a couple kids who would play goalie and it was normally the athletically gifted since they could actually stop shots or disrupt attackers.
Our Karen had taught their goalies to "go grab the ball." If you have played football, you can probably see where telling 9-10 yr olds to just "go grab the ball" may be a bad idea. The goalies were running out and reaching for the ball as the attackers were still dribbling it. The attackers were not ready for this and the first time it happened it worked really well because the surprise meant the goalie picked up the ball without any real challenge. That was the last time the attackers were surprised.
The next time down the field, the goalie comes running out to grab the ball, and the attacker just kicks it past her. No big deal, good choice since you know the keeper runs out too far. Well, apparently our Karen disagreed because what I heard was, "Yupitsanalt, why didn't you call that?" I was understandably confused as it was fair play and there was nothing to call. My logic went to offside as that is potentially what happened, but I was confident it was not as I could see two defenders behind the keeper when the pass was made and no player was really running forward from the attacker. Game went on.
Another attack is coming in. This time the keeper dives for the ball and the attacker has a poor strike straight into the keeper's stomach. I hold up play to get the coach out to check on her player. She comes to me, rather than the player, red faced and yells "WHY DIDN'T YOU CALL THAT PENALTY?" I am again confused as nothing was wrong with any of the play that would normally be a penalty and I ask, "what are you talking about?"
Karen proceeds to yell at me that I was ignoring goalie interference and that her player was hurt because I didn't call it earlier so the other team just kept going at the goalie. In my head I am starting to panic a little because as a 14 yr old being yelled at by an adult is very stressful to me. I manage to get some semblance of control and reply, "That wasn't interference, the other player had the ball, your goalie tried to grab it from them and they kicked it which is fine."
Unfortunately, I didn't have all the customer service experience I have now so I failed to realize that no matter what, it was my fault. Our Karen's response to my answer, "How can you say that? My goalie is right there grabbing the ball, they have to be protected from being hurt. You screwed up and that means my player is hurt!"
As I was completely overwhelmed by her yelling at me, I decided to just try to get the game going again and said, "I will watch for it." HUGE mistake because there wasn't anything to "watch" for. I did go and check in with the goalie and told her that if the other player was still kicking the ball, she should just get big and block the goal rather than trying to grab it. She thanked me for the advice and the game resumed. I thought we were good now because the goalie was doing much better and even stopped a couple shots playing the way I encouraged.
Well, this wouldn't be a story if that was the end of it. Halftime came and went. Apparently the coach had a discussion because first chance, goalie tries to come and grab the ball off a players foot. Thankfully this time the attacker just made a nice move and scored so no injury. Except to Karen's ego.
"YUPITSANALT WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT? THAT WAS A PENALTY WE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN SCORED ON."
Something happened in that moment. I remembered only one thing that I learned in referee training, that field is YOUR field when you are the center ref. You can send people off, and you do not have to put up with abuse. Thankfully, an amazing mentor who had helped me so much had also showed me how to deal with an angry parent and discussed it with me a couple times. Remembering Lionel's teachings, I walked over to the sideline and said, "Coach, may I speak to you over here?" and invited Karen on to the field. She stepped over with me a few feet away from the sideline.
"I understand that you are asking me to call a penalty every time your goalie goes for the ball with her hands. That is not a penalty. The goalie is allowed to put herself in the way, but it's her call. If she does and they kick it away from her, that's not a penalty, it's soccer. A penalty is if she has possession of the ball in her hands and the try to kick it out or she dives on it and covers it up and they kick it after she has it. That is not happening and every time the other team still has control."
Well, this went over like one would expect. "That is wrong. You know that is wrong and we will be calling the referee coordinator after to tell her about your mistakes. You must start making the right call now because our player is going to be hurt because of you."
Forgive me for what I did next, because I was 14 yrs old.
I responded as calmly as my very nervous and shaken self could, "No, I will not. And if you yell at me about it again, you have to leave the area and cannot return until I have left." In my head, I wanted her to yell at me at that moment. I wanted to either call the game a forfeit or to be able to get her the hell away from me. Neither happened, instead I was told; "oh Yupitsanalt, you can't make me leave, just make the right call and we will be fine." She walked back to the sideline smug as she could be. I knew what was coming and decided to say something to the keeper about what was and what was not a penalty. I wanted her if she dove for the ball and was harmed, it was not a penalty and that being big and blocking was safer and more effective.
Clearly the keeper was more worried about the coach than about me. Next attack she makes a dive for the ball, and the attacker kicked it hard straight into her face. No blood, but it 100% hurt. Karen starts screaming at me and calling me a horrible person for not protecting her player. I respond in a very 14 year old with some power way and shout, "THAT'S IT GET THE HELL AWAY FROM MY FIELD!"
Karen of course looks at me like I grew a third eye and some tentacles and shouts, "you can't make me leave. I am a coach and you are just the referee." I hit that cold calm that we all feel when you realize you are in the right and that even if the shit hits the fan, ultimately you are still going to be right.
"Karen, you have 30 seconds to be beyond that fence (about 300 feet away by the parking lot) or I will report a forfeit to the club for your team." I look down at my watch and wait. She stands there dumbfounded and in shock. We did keep records and there was a tournament teams took WAY too seriously at the end of the season. The team with the best record was also crowned the "Champions" of their age group. The other parents started to tell her to just walk away and that they would "take care of him" when they spoke to the club.
It hit the 30 second mark and I raised my hand and put my whistle in my mouth to call it a forfeit. Karen finally realized that I wasn't kidding and she seemed to maybe think it would stick as a loss so she walked to the fence. Her assistant tried to explain, "She was just trying to protect our player." I ignored him and the rest of the game went ok. Till the final whistle.
Karen starts walking back over to the field. I noticed and shouted, "Hey, if you take another step closer, it's a forfeit." She just ignored me and walked to the field. Her team had won, but at that point I blew the game end and shouted "Forfeit, \*other team\* wins" She blew up at me and just started calling me spoiled and that she was going to get me fired and that I was in serious trouble.
Thankfully it was my last game and my dad was waiting for me. I got in the car and just bawled all the way home because I couldn't speak. I called the club's ref coordinator and explained what happened and the results of the games. The ref coordinator promised to never schedule me for her games the rest of the season and did back me up saying that it sounded like I did the right thing. I just hoped the whole thing was done and I wouldn't have to deal with any of this again. Yeah, not happening.
That next week our referee coordinator called and let me know that the club no longer needed me to referee because of my "immature" behavior at that game and she chewed me out for talking to an adult so disrespectfully. I started crying again and was crushed because I loved refereeing and the pay was quite good. At that moment, my mom stepped in and decided to see if she could help. Mom called the club's overall director and apparently two of the board members and shared my story. She asked them to check with the other team and coach to see if maybe my story was a better fit because of course the whole talked to the coach politely as a warning and the attempts to tell the keeper the safer way to play were left out. As was the fact that this adult was screaming at me from the sideline and during the game. It was entirely just some kid told an adult to pound sand when she was just "protecting her player"
I am not sure of all the steps. I only know who my mom called to help me because she told me names and I know what their role was. The outcome was another call from the assistant referee coordinator who let me know that I would still be receiving assignments and not to worry, I would not have to deal with that team as they would put me at different fields from where they played. To me, I was just relieved that I still had my job. At 14, being fired for doing what I was sure was right was just painful. I also know that I never heard from the main referee coordinator again. I know she was still involved with the club as she was at some of the pre-season meetings the next couple years, just not sure what she was doing.
The Karen did get to keep coaching, but the forfeit stayed and in the end, they were in the middle of the pack. One more win would have sorta helped, but not a lot really. Their opponent was at the same level, so that one change was not a big deal. I know it would not have moved either team to the trophies for the top 3. I remained a ref till I was 20 when I just decided I was "too busy." It was not the last time I had issues with a coach, but it was the one that still sticks with me.
I actually coach with the same club I played with as a kid and my kids have played for the club since they were little. I love coaching, and one of my favorite parts is that if you treat a referee with even the slightest hint of disrespect, it's a ban. Not just you, your kids too. 100% for one year and permanently from trying out for competitive levels. The club at some point, and the state soccer commission, decided that allowing adults to yell at kids is not ok.