(Crosspost) Breaking New Info: A Portion of ALL Your Shares Are Possibly Being Moved to DTC on Cutoff Days to Suppress the DRS counts. What is a “DSPP Share”, and How Short Hedge Funds Are Causing Household Investor's Shares to be Moved.
I did post it yesterday as well, but it was removed by automod as the post includes links to another subreddit and I had added a link to the original posters account. I have communicated with the mod team on this subreddit and they said to try again without that information and without direct links.
The below post has been copied in its entirety from another subreddit (except for removal of other embedded links), and at the request of the original poster 6days1week I am posting it to this sub for further discussion.
---
Ok, wow, so where to start. I’ve been working on the information (below) actively for 6 weeks. I was led to this research based on a conversation I had with another household investor. She couldn’t get straight answers from Computershare chat (trying over half a dozen times) why DRS book shares were “forced” to adhere to the same terms and conditions as the plan shares in her account. She was specifically inquiring about dividend reinvestment at the time. After I had a few Computershare chat conversations myself (one of which is shown below), I came to the same conclusion, and that’s what ignited the fire in me to find out what was going on.
This led me to Nordstrom stock as I already owned one DRS book share, and they were scheduled to pay a cash dividend on March 29th. I had no plan shares (and dividend reinvestment turned off), so my account was a “pure DRS account.” Another household investor helped me determine that I still had time to buy a plan share (plus fractional) before the ex-dividend date. I quickly made a one-time direct purchase for plan shares, and barely beat the deadline. Finally, this would give me the “real life example” regarding what was actually happening. The test I performed was to determine if I would receive “cash” for my book share and receive dividend reinvestment for my plan share(s). After talking with chat reps in mid March, they told me “this isn’t possible.”, which was the same answer that the first household investor got when she had asked a month or two earlier. **According to Computershare, if I owned a plan share, then I needed to think of my book and plan shares as “one account.”**
To recap: Nordstrom was offering a $0.19 cash dividend, and the stock was currently trading around $17 at the time of the dividend. I owned one book designation share with dividend reinvestment disabled, and I purchased one share (plus a fractional) in plan designation. I was hoping to receive two separate dividend payouts: one for $0.19 cash, and one that would go towards buying $0.19+ toward a new share. Trying to keep a long story short, when the Nordstrom dividend came, all shares received dividend reinvestment. **It turns out that buying or holding even a single plan share enrolls your entire account into DirectStock plan. ALL your shares become “part of the plan.”** Fast forward past more and more research, this led me to the creation of the charts below (with the help of another household investor).
​
https://preview.redd.it/t1smkpmrrcua1.png?width=1262&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=bff9f95896dc331ccf323f56604cd210a96dbfcc
https://preview.redd.it/pup5vokvrcua1.png?width=1766&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=2e341b7d73ec68ab1734d2641e0a4068c099fb54
These diagrams made it simple to understand, but there was still one more thing missing. **How does this affect the numbers disclosed in 10-Q and 10-K reports?** This led me to more research. What are these shares “in the plan” called? It was always assumed by household investors that any “DRS book shares” are what Computershare calls “pure DRS.” It turns out that this assumption is incorrect. “Pure DRS” is a form of HOLDING. DRS book shares (that are not part of the DirectStock plan) are “Pure DRS book” (shown in green). DRS book shares that ARE enrolled in the plan are NOT what Computershare calls “pure” (shown above in yellow and orange). **So, what are ALL shares enrolled in “the plan” called regardless of whether they are plan or book? It turns out that Computershare specifically calls them “DSPP shares.” Household investors always assumed that “plan share = DSPP share,” when in reality it turns out that “all shares enrolled in the plan = DSPP shares.”**
​
https://preview.redd.it/swtbsgu9scua1.png?width=1156&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=f6edcf358cb42363aa00f89a4d3c9eb6ca62a392
https://preview.redd.it/3vys4dlcscua1.png?width=1154&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=7b207fd75493dcb54a38e3f794844f9d6b9774bf
We all know that chat logs are not direct proof , but I wanted to include these screenshots to make you aware that chat representatives are aware of the difference, and may explain the specifics of DirectStock holdings when asked. Now that you have this information, it will allow you to ask the right questions using the right language.
The Computershare FAQ makes it clear that it is DSPP that allows for shareholders to elect for dividend reinvestment, whereas DRS shares do not require enrollment into a plan, and there is no need to make elections around dividend payments. Hold onto that thought, because I show below that if you decide to end DirectStock plan (aka DSPP), you need to “terminate” the dividend reinvestment plan. Similarly, if you hold all Book shares but have dividend reinvestment ON, you need to “terminate” dividend reinvestment in order to leave the DirectStock plan. As the FAQ below indicates, there is no need to select a dividend payment allocation - your account will simply be credited a cash dividend in the form of cash.
https://preview.redd.it/etktqhlvscua1.png?width=1004&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=c18705a916173f32446139c46ffc69bf48aded21
[https://www.computershare.com/us/becoming-a-registered-shareholder-in-us-listed-companies#drs-shares](https://www.computershare.com/us/becoming-a-registered-shareholder-in-us-listed-companies#drs-shares)
This is a massive breakthrough because it means the OLD assumption that if you owned 1000.1 shares (1000 being DRS and 0.1 being plan) that you owned 1000 pure DRS book shares and 0.1 DSPP share. This is completely incorrect. If you hold 1000.1 shares, it means that you hold 1000.1 DSPP shares. A portion of ALL those shares are held at DTC for operational efficiency. **Yes, in the hypothetical example above, by owning the 0.1 fractional plan share, you are allowing a portion of the other 1000 to be moved to DTC “for operational efficiency”.**
Now, that’s going to take some time to absorb, so maybe read that paragraph above again. Take a few deep breaths, because it’s about to get wilder. “Buckle up” as household investors have heard before. My “heat lamp theory” (a link to another reddit post regarding this theory has been removed) concludes that the “rug pull” on DRS account numbers is being done with household investors’ own shares specifically on cutoff days. The theory is that the “portion of aggregate DSPP shares held at DTC for operational efficiency” is tied to an algorithm that is based on real time volume and price.** When volume and price are relatively flat, very few shares will be held at DTC “for operational efficiency”. **When volume and price get volatile, it is “necessary” for Computershare to hold more shares at DTC.**
If you were a short hedge fund, and you knew this fairly simple algorithm, what do you think they are going to do on cutoff days to confuse household investors? They would make the volume go bonkers so that the algorithm kicks in and completes the DRS count manipulation for them. Check out the highest volume days in the last 6 months. **This is going to blow your mind, “coincidentally" the highest volume days by FAR (in the last 6 months) are the days that the shares were counted.**
​
https://preview.redd.it/edybhaubvcua1.png?width=1000&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=c73a3e40b662e5d89dc471d5e7f05b5b4a04c947
Notice how Computershared.Net Raw estimates and DRS GME reported numbers nearly merge in July and then diverge for the Q3 DRS report date. Some folks are suggesting that Computershared.Net Raw (non-trimmed) estimates have been right since July and the true number of DRS shares in Computershare is closer to 100 million. In this case, the above chart could be revised to look like this:
https://preview.redd.it/z2nuzylr2gua1.png?width=1964&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=04524bf4ec3fa7f99991b45a795ec952a34ec9dc
So, what happens NEXT? My speculation is that since this wasn’t uncovered until now (just 2 weeks before the next cutoff) that short hedge funds are going to create a lot of volume for GME at least one more time before (possibly) modifying their plan for future cutoffs. The next cutoff “should be” Saturday, April 29th. **I believe the stock “should” spike in volume sometime between April 28th and May 2nd. More specifically, I think the volume spike will happen May 1st with much of the trading volume happening in after hours.** Since the cutoff is on a day that the market is closed, I believe Computershare tallies the counts at the close of after market hours on the first full trading day after the cutoff date.
https://preview.redd.it/mmybxpm2wcua1.png?width=626&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=768dfb6548096be5ab68e681d931020e5769d605
# With that being said, how can you make sure your shares are completely out of the DTC at all times even during cutoff days?
# 1) You can not own any plan shares (which includes a fractional share).
# 2) You can not be enrolled in dividend reinvestment (even if you are 100% book)*
# 3) You can not be enrolled in recurring buys on Computershare.
# 4) You can not have a limit order placed
\*”How to terminate plan” pictorial is located at the bottom of this post
Now hold on, that sounds fuddy as shit, and I agree with you! I’ve been buying through Computershare and maintained automatic reinvestment for months, like many of you. Please don’t shoot the messenger. I’m not here to tell you what to do, I’m just here to tell you what I’ve found. I'm here to tell you the changes that I made to my own account (last week), and I’m here to tell you what I think will happen next before it actually happens.
Before anyone claims this post is "Computershare fud", I want to be clear on a couple things. Owning fractional shares is normally fine. Dividend reinvestment is good for everyone (issuers, investors, and transfer agents). Recurring buys are normally GREAT. Computershare isn't doing anything wrong, The reality is that short hedge funds found a crack in the system (like they always do) so they can "legally" manipulate the numbers that they want to manipulate. Steps 1 to 4 (above) close that crack (for now).
Continuing to buy at brokers and transferring out is one way to force DTC withdrawal. Another option is to maintain the reinvestment plan or Computershare buys, while making sure to disable them and follow the above 4 points when DRS stock is tallied for the quarterly reports. You are not able to pause the plan if you have a pending limit buy, which means people buying biweekly have a very small window to close the plan without waiting a full cycle. In April I believe there are/were only 5 days that recurring buys can be cancelled.
Either way, I expect that GME investors will see a massive outlier day in terms of volume, and then once the financial report has been filed, GME investors will see that the high volume outlier day was also the day DRS numbers were tallied.
One last mention is that “what if the stock doesn’t have a large volume spike sometime between April 28th and May 2nd? Does that mean my “heat lamp theory” (a link to another reddit post regarding this theory has been removed) is wrong? No, not necessarily. Household investors won’t know for sure until the next 10-Q is released at the end of May. One thing I want to mention is that I hope there isn't an artificial spike. The numbers should be the numbers. Suppressive manipulation shouldn't exist. Now that I got that out of the way, if the stock doesn’t spike in volume during that time, here’s why that may be the case::
1) The cutoff day is wrong (or got moved). This happened with the 10-K just last month where household investors thought the cutoff would be Jan 28. It ended up being March 22 which was inconsistent with the cutoff from the previous 10-K a year earlier.
2) Short hedge funds decided not to create a volume spike for the stock this time, and they are allowing the numbers to come in where they should be (high). Hypothetically if short hedge funds don’t create volume for the stock this time on the cutoff date, and the count comes in at something like 100 million, they could then spike the volume the next time (3 months from now) causing the count to come in low again at something like 85 million. That is a strategy that would still create confusion.
Do you want to confirm whether or not your shares are DSPP shares (aka enrolled in DirectStock)? Just look at your statement. If you have any plan shares (even a fractional), your Computershare statement will have DirectStock on the top, like these:
​
https://preview.redd.it/a22k07eh8dua1.png?width=640&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=aa976e3449bc9d580505afe61491930d398e7a24
https://preview.redd.it/5wlyf5vo8dua1.png?width=668&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=3e8c0068eb58af35221f6ac67c1207ede2aa3627
If you have NO plan shares (not even a fractional) and you have turned “dividend reinvestment turned OFF,” your statement will simply have “Direct Registration Advice” at the top like this:
https://preview.redd.it/go29ywou8dua1.png?width=592&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=77fb8a7547c301bae0491befd2212b07d75c7211
# *How to cancel Plan and terminate dividend reinvestment in pictures:
​
https://preview.redd.it/cnyoaw509dua1.png?width=410&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=2a66f085263ab0c39a32e4be9542af225f8562f0
https://preview.redd.it/6mo1umb69dua1.png?width=514&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=8db182ece6e7c1c3b81d02d7f4180176409ae666
Congratulations! You are now what Paul Conn referred to as “Pure DRS Book” (aka “Pure DRS Book Account”) and your statements will no longer have the DirectStock header. Instead, they will simply have “Direct Registration (DRS) Advice” on the top, like this: