In defense of Anna Nardini
I know this is going to be an unpopular view on this much maligned character but… I think Anna was trying pretty hard in the beginning to accommodate Luke’s relationship with April. She explained herself clearly about why she didn’t include him in April’s life before the big discovery. But I think she was really explaining why she didn’t want Luke her in life, too.
Look at how Luke was treating Lorelai during this time. Shutting her out and basically lying to her. Telling her that he didn’t want her to meet April because if she did April would like Lorelai more and “it would be over” for him.
Luke’s history is not great. He js really mean to and about Dean and Logan. This is a grown man who was going to fight Dean when he was still a minor. He’s mean to and about his sister early on. He’s mean to and about Rachel. He’s mean to everyone at some point. Some of this is very low level justified. But he’s an emotional punisher. Almost an emotional abuser. Look how he treats strangers and customers. Look how he treated his customers when he broke up with Lorelai.
So imagine how he must have been to Anna during their relationship and breakup. She probably had good reason to not want an emotionally immature, distant, and kind of cruel dude in her kid’s life.
How many times does he have to be coached by Lulu and Lorelai in how not to be mean to little kids in town. He is so mean to kids they need their asthma inhalers. He angrily rants about people bringing their babies into the diner on the weekends. And he had admitted just a few episodes before April showed up that he hates spending time with Sookie’s kids. He’s mean to April’s friends at the birthday party and doesn’t even know he’s being overbearing and unkind.
So why would Anna want him in her life hating a child and being overbearing to her and resenting the whole situation? I mean - the second time he’s going to spend time with April he tries to get out of it so he can keep lying to Lorelai.
I understand that most people think Anna should have told Luke he had a child. But did she absolutely know he was the father? No. Can you imagine going through the paternity process with Luke Danes and his crap attitude and mean disposition? I can see why she didn’t tell a man who had made it clear he hated kids. And he was no longer in her life.
Ok… I get it if you disagree. But Luke is not a nice guy at least 50% of the time. So imagine he is your baby daddy. Yuck.