RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/GrayZoneWarfare • … • u/Enigma89_YT

I hate to say this but to me GZW seems like a better game than Tarkov but the combat is not nearly as satisfying

Let me be preface by saying that these are two different games and they can co-exist, it's better for us that we have a lot of different flavours of this genre. With that said, I have very limited time to play these days and when I am in the mood to play an extraction shooter, I have to decide between GZW or Tarkov so this is why I made this comparison.

In general, I think GZW, despite being in early access, is actually a fantastic game. The scale of the map, the seamless experience, huge QOL improvements vs tarkov and the runway this game is building into makes it all really exciting. I totally stopped playing Tarkov a few years ago and playing GZW made me want to jump back into Tarkov in a really ironic way, why? The Combat.

One thing that drove me crazy about Tarkov was mag dumping into a guy only to have him hop away and the game did not really reward great positioning. This was frustrating and one of the reasons why I stopped playing Tarkov. Now playing GZW, I am starting to actually slip back into Tarkov for the first time in years. The reason is because i am finding the fights very unsatisfying in GZW, the fights are not really fights, they are executions.

What I mean by this is that, when I have a PVP encounter, it generally happens with me hearing gun fire as I approach a city or village. I walk up, from the jungle, and see a guy and I simply just head tap him. That's it. That's the fight (read execution). What happens from there is then a race to grab his loot before this guy helicopters back. If he is in a duo, then I won't risk looting the body because I know the 2nd guy will hold the body until his buddy can get back. The whole helicopter back mechanic is one that makes things to feel really bad. We have this giant map that is beautiful and all of a sudden, it becomes a dog pile in an area because the same 3-4 guys are all flying back to the same spot to get their gear again. The fights that happen after people fly back are always really crappy.

Tarkov is a bit different. Awful game with really stupid mechanics but the combat has a tiny bit more of a brawlier style and it extends peak moments. The combat is the only thing that makes tarkov redeeming and to me GZW feels like the opposite. Everything in GZW is really solid but the combat just feels very unsatisfying. Hard to find consistent PVP and when you do its over suddenly and then is there eventual dogpile after from a bunch of naked guys with M4s trying to jump you as you leave.

I had this thought in my head so I wanted to share it out. I am very much not a giant Tarkov fan. I have 1.5K hours in that game and I found myself rage quitting that game but, with playing and enjoying GZW, I actually reinstalled tarkov again for the first time again. What an awful experience but the few fights I have had playing Tarkov again have all felt way more satisfying than the quick executions happening in GZW.

Wonder what we all think. Thanks

— 0